Re-thinking shaming Practices in African [Igbo] Traditional Society as a Viable Option for Maintaining Justice, Social Integration and Moral Development in Modern Africa

Authors

  • Kingsley Okoro

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.14738/assrj.34.1533

Abstract

The history of crime dates back to historical antiquity and this is an outgrowth of human capriciousness and avarice, which made everyone an atom and a law unto himself in the social order. This situation hinders human mutuality and cooperation which is needed for human survival, development and progress.  Guided by reason, man had to notch out morns/ laws that will guide human relationship and maintain social justice. These rules have been notched with their consequences. The technical name for the consequences is “Shaming” Shaming practices vary according to the degree of offence and in relations to time and context. While some shaming practices involve capital punishment others involve reprimanding, which may include the incarceration of the offender in prison and subsequent parole.  However, the overall aim of shaming is social cleansing of the society that has been desecrated by the criminal act. Nevertheless, this paper notes that the present shaming model is alien to African [Igbo] culture and as such have failed to achieve its purpose. Therefore, it begins a re-thinking of an indigenous shaming model that allies with African culture as to bring about the positive social effect of shaming ideality in the society and this is  the resocialization and reintegration of the offender into the society after a period of shaming ritual. Using the  socio-anthropological method, this paper underscores the if African [Igbo] indigenous shaming model is adopted as a means of adjudicating social justice in the modern era our dream of crime free African society shall soon be realized.         

References

Ashby JS, Rice, KG and Martin J.C [2006]. ‘Perfectionism, Shame and Depression Symptoms’, Journal of Counselling and Development 2006:84 [148P156] retrieved from www.shamingpracticesinthemodernworld.edu/org on 23rd April, 2015.

Baker Phil [2003]. What is Guilt? What is Shame? Beyond Intractability Project. Colorado. The Conflict Information Consortium[1P7] retrieved from www.shameandshamingculture.org/edu. On 27th March, 2015. Barnard Jayne W [2015] RePintegrative Shaming in Corporate Sentencing. Restorative Justice Online. Mooball I.T. Centre for Justice and Reconciliation. Retrieved from http://justicearticle.org/shame.edu on 12th April, 2015.

Bear GG, UribePZarain X, Manning MA, Shiomi K [2009]. ‘Shame, Guilt, Blaming and Anger: Differences between Children in Japan and the U S’. Motivations and Emotions. [2009]:33:229P238. Retrieved from http://shamingcultureinmodernworld.edu/org. on 24th of March, 2015.

Benedict Ruth., [2015] ‘Shame’ see Wikipedia: The Free Encyclopaedia. www.shamepracticeinancientsocieties.org/edu. Retrieved on March 12, 2015.

Braithwaite John [1989]. Crime, Shame and Reintegration. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Retrieved from http://shamingculture.org/edu on 12th April, 2015.

Braithwaite John and Mungford B[1994]. ‘Conditions of Successful RePIntegrative Ceremonies’ British Journal of Criminology vol,3 No 2[1994] retrieved from http://justiceedu/article.org on 24th March, 2015.

Brewin, Cr, Andrew, B. Rose, S. [2000]. ‘Fear, Helplessness and Horror in PostPTraumatic Stress Disorder: Investigating DSMPWestevion A2 in Victims of Violent Crime’ Journal of Traumatic Stress. 2000:13 [499P509] retrieved from www.shameandmodernculyure,edu/org. on 30th March,2015.

Chad Cusworth, brain Danniels, Emily Rondi [2015]. The Ethics of Public Shaming. Retrieved from www.shamingculture/education.org. on 23rd March, 2015.

Charles Horton C [1992] Human Nature and Social Order. New York: Scribners.

David Karp and Todd Clear., [2000]. Community Justice: A Conceptual Framework: Boundary Change in Criminal Justice Organization’ Journal of Criminal Justice. Vol.6 No. 4 [2000]. 323P363.

Davidson. B., [1969]. The African Genius. Boston: Navigation Publishing.

Ejizu, Christopher. I., [2014]. ‘African Community Living’ see www.africansocialjustice/html/edu.org.127045031725. Retrieved on 23/01/2014.

Fossum, Merle A and Mason Mailyn J[ 1986] Facing Shame: Families in Recovery. WW Norton. Retrieved from www.moderncultureandshamingpractice.org/edu. On the 12th April,2015.

Fukuyama Francis [2001] ‘Social Capital, Civil Society and Development’. Third World Quarterly Vol 22 No 1 [1P 20]

George H.S and Thomas L. Thorson, [1973]. A History of Political Theory [4th edition] New Delhi: Oxford &IBH Publishing.

HannemPKish Stancy, Crime, Shame and Reintegration. Encyclopaedia of Prison and Correctional Faculties ed. Thousand waks. LA. Sage 2004:201.05 reference online web 1 august, 2012. Retrieved from shamingculture.org/edu on 23rd March, 2015.

Iwe, N.S.S., [1991]. ‘Sociological Approach to the Study of African Traditional Religion and Culture’ A paper presented at the 6th Annual Conference of National Association of African Religions. May 6, 1991 [1P24].

Jennifer, Jacquet [2015] Is Shame Necessary? Excerpted from Future Sciences: Essays from the Cutting Edge. Edited by Max Brozkman NJ. Vintage Books. Retrieved from www.cuttingedge.org on the 23th March, 2015.

Okoro,'K.'(2016).'ReBThinking'Shaming'Practices'in'African'(Igbo)'Traditional'Society'as'a'Viable'Option'for'Maintaining'Justice,'Social'Integration' Julian A Deonna, Raffaele Rodogno and Fabrice Teroni [2012]. ‘In Defence of shame: The Faces of an Emotion’ Notre Dame Philosophical Review, College of Arts and Letters. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Retrieved from www.shameandshamingcultureinmodernstudies. On 12th April, 2015.

Kahan Dan M [1996] What Does Alternative Sanction Mean? University of Chicago Law Review 63:593. Retrieved from www.socialjusticemodel/edu.org. on 12th April, 2015.

Karp David R. [2015]. Shame and Criminal Justice. Washington DC: Centre for Communitarian Policy Studies George Washington University. Retrieved from http://criminaljustice.org/areticle.edu. On 12th April, 2015.

Kaufman, Gershen [1992], Shame: The Power of Caring [3rd edition] Rochester: Schenkman Books Leviathan Chapter XIIIPXIV.

Lewis Helen b [1971] Shame and Guilt in Neurosis Study. NY International University Press.

Mashiro, Morioke., [1991]. ‘The Concept of ‘Inochi’: A Philosophical Perspective on the Study of Life’ Japanese Review Vol.2, 1991 [83P115].

Massaro, Toni M[2008] Shame Culture and American Criminal Justice Law. Dayton: University of Dayton. Retrieved from www.justiceeducation.org/edu. On 12th April, 2015.

Mead FS [1999] ‘Shaming as a Positive Culture’ Sociological Review 46 [1999] 102P109. Retrieved from www.shamingcultureinmodernperiod.edu/org. on 24th March, 2015.

Norman Bales [2015] Coping with Shame and Guilt. Retrieved from http://fbgPchurch.org/article/guilt.htm

Odey, John O., [2005]. Africa: The Agony of a Continent: Can Liberation Theology offer any Solution? [2 edition] Enugu: Snaap Press.

Okafor, F.U., [1992]. Igbo Philosophy of Law. Enugu: Fourth Dimension.

Okafor, N., [2006]. ‘Relevance of African Traditional Jurisprudence on Control, Justice and Law: A Critique of Igbo Experience’ African Journal of Criminology and Justice Studies. No. 1, June 2006 [35P58].

Okoro, Kingsley [2014] ‘Utopianism and the New World Order: A Critical Consideration’ Open Journal of Philosophy 2014.4 [332P334] published August, 2014. http://www.scrip.org/journal/ojpp.http://olx.doi.org/10.4236/ojpp.2014.43037.

Okoro, Kingsley and Njoku Donatus [2012] ‘Religion, Social Capital and the New World Order: A Reconsideration’ Proceeding of International Conference on Research and Development Held in the University Auditorium, University of Lome. Republic of Togo. May 14P17 [2012] 50P64.

Okoro, Kingsley and Osunwokeh Clement [2014]. ‘Religion and Human Rights Violation in History: The Women and Witch Hunts in Medieval Europe’ Journal of Scientific Research and Report 3 [24] 3045P3067

Jsrr.2014.24:1102.www.sciencedomain.org.

Okoro, Kingsley N., [2009]. ‘Cultural Globalization the Last Onslaught on African Personality: The Igbo Example’. International Journal of Philosophy and Religion Vol 1. No.1. [26P38].

Okoro, Kingsley. N. and Okoli Charles,. [2014] ‘The Synergy Between Social Justice and Compassion in African [Igbo] Traditional Society: A Reconsideration’ Scholars Journal of Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences. 2014:2 [63] 922P933. Available @ http://sasjournals.com/sjahss.

Okoro, Kingsley. N., [2010]. ‘African Traditional Education: A viable Alternative for Peace Building Process in Modern Africa’. Online Journal of Alternative Perspective in Social Sciences, Vol. 2, No. 1. 2010. [136P159] http://www.japss.org.editorial.journaljapss.

Okoro, Kingsley. N., [2013]. ‘African Concept of ‘Inochi’: A New Paradigm for Peace Education in the Contemporary Society’. Modern Social Science Journal 2[2013].No.2 P87P112. Available online at http://www.scik.org.

Okoro, Kingsley. N., [2015] ‘The Theory and Practice of Social Justice in African Traditional Society through Compassion and Community Living’ In Conversation in Compassion edited by Michelle Brenner. Sydney: University of Sydney Press. [1P21].

Onyeozili and Ebbe., ‘Social Control in PrePColonial Igbo Land of Nigeria’ African Journal of Criminolgy and Justice studies. 2012; 6 [1&2] 29P44.

Oraegbunnam. I., [2014] ‘Crime and Punishment in Igbo Customary Law: The Challenge of Nigeria Criminal Jurisprudence’ Journal of Criminal Justice Vol.5, No.8 2014 [1P31].

Ruth Benedict [2015]. The Culture of Shame’ In Wikipedia ‘Shame’ Free Encyclopaedia retrieved from www.cultureofshameandshaming/modernsociety.org. on 12th April, 2015.

Sandrine, Theresa and Martin Brain [2010] Shame, Scientist Degradation Ritual in Science. Prometheus Vol.28 No 2 June, 2010 [97P110].

Scheff Thomas and Retzinger S [1991] Emotions and Violence: Shame and Rage Spirals in Interminable Conflict. Lexington: Lexington Books.

Scheff Thomas J [1988] ‘Shame and Conformity: Deference of Emotional System’ American Sociological Review 35[1988] 405P409. Retrieved from www.shamingcultureinmodernworld.edu.org. on 23rd April, 2015. Scheff Thomas J [2015] Shame and Social Bond retrieved from www.shamingcultureorg/edu. On 12th April, 2015.

Shorter, Alyward., [2013]. ‘The Concept of Social Justice in African Traditional Society’ see www.africansocialjustice.alyward.edu/org. Retrieved on November 12, 2014 [1P22]

Tangney J.P [1990] ‘Assessing Individual Differences in Proneness to Shame and Guilt: Development of Self Conscious Affect and Attribution inventory’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology [102P111[ Pubmed. Retrieved from www.shameculture.edu/org. on 23rd April,2015.

Tangney June Price, Stuewing Jelf and Hafex Logain [2012]. Shame, Guilt and Remorse: Implication for Offending Population. J.Forens Psychiatry Psychol. 2011 Sept 1, 22[5] 706P723 doi. 10.1080/14789949.2011.617541. Tomlison John., [2003]. Globalization and Cultural Identity. See www.polity.co.uk/pdf/glreaderzetomlisonpdf. Retrieved on August 16, 2009.

Wamala. E., [2014] ‘The SocioPPolitical Philosophy of Traditional Burgundy Society: Break and Continuity into the Present’ see www.justiceinafrica. Retrieved on January 12, 2014.

Downloads

Published

2016-04-09

How to Cite

Okoro, K. (2016). Re-thinking shaming Practices in African [Igbo] Traditional Society as a Viable Option for Maintaining Justice, Social Integration and Moral Development in Modern Africa. Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal, 3(4). https://doi.org/10.14738/assrj.34.1533