Adaptability of Liberalism and Shiite Political Theory in the Thoughts of Allameh Naieni, A Theoretical Framework for the Iranian Constitutional Revolution

Authors

  • Aref Barkhordari University of Tehran, Iran
  • Mohammad Reza Metanat University of Tehran, Iran

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.14738/assrj.111.16158

Keywords:

Constitution, legitimacy, tyranny, Islamic law, parliament, law, constitutional system

Abstract

The purpose of writing this article is to analyze and describe the political thought of Allameh Mohammad Hossein Naeini as one of the most important theorists of the Iranian Constitutional Revolution (1284 AH), who tried to reconcile the components of liberalism and classical Shiite political thought to provide a Theoretical basis for the Iranian Constitutional Revolution. In this article, the treatise "Tanbih al-Ulama and Tanzih al-Mulla is, the most important work of Naeini and some other works that have studied her thought, are examined. In Iranian Constitutional Revolution, those who defended the Constitution against   supporters of tyranny began to write their treatises, mainly during period of minor tyrann[1]. The most important goal of these thinkers in writing the treatises is to eliminate tyranny, reduce king, s power and rulers in political system of Qajar period and limiting them to the law of parliament and public will on one hand and explaining the concepts and foundations of liberalism and constitutionalism in a way that is compatible with Islamic law on the other hand. In justifying constitutionalism these treatises has referred more to weaknesses and harms of authoritarian system, as well as to poverty and backwardness of Iranian society, and considered constitutionalism to be the only solution to problems.The aim of these dissertations was to demonstrate the efficiencies and capabilities of Constitution in preserving and strengthening the Iranian society. In fact, they are in line with times have sought to implement a religious copy of liberal system and Western constitution in Iranian society. The most important treatise that written in this field is the book of Tanbih al-Allameh and Tanzih al-Mella written by Mohammad Hussein Naeini which we will examine his theories in this article.

References

Abadian, H. 1995. Theoretical Foundations of Constitutional and Legitimate Government in Iran, Tehran, Ney Publishing.

______________. 2004. Constitutional Crisis in Iran, Tehran, Institute of Islamic Studies and Research.

Ajoudani, M. 2005. Iranian Constitution. Tehran, Akhtaran Publishing.

Afrough, J. 2004. Religious Modernism and Democracy in Iran. Tehran, New Step publishing.

Barkhordari, Aref. 2022. "A short history of liberalism in contemporary Iran," Constitutional Political Economy, Springer, vol. 33(2), pages 200-216, June. DOI: 10.1007/s10602-021-09343-9.

Barkhordari, Aref. 2020. Systematization and the Model of Political Management in Contemporary Iranian Thinker’s Idea. Journal of Social Science Studies. Vol. 7, No. 2. P 57-71. https://doi.org/10.5296/jsss.v7i2.16937.

Haeri, A. 1985. Shiism and constitutionalism in Iran. Tehran. Amirkabir publishing.

Hosseinizadeh, M A. 2007. Political Islam in Iran. Qom, Mofid University publishing.

Haghdar, A A. 2003. Political Power in Iranian Thought. Tehran, New Plan publishing.

Halabi, A A. 1994. History of Political Thoughts in Iran and the Islamic World. Tehran, Behbahani publishing.

Rahbari, M. 2008. The failed constitution, a reflection on the Iranians' confrontation with the Janus face of modernity. Tehran, Kavir Publishing.

Rahbari, M. 2009. Constitutionalism and modernity: the history of developments in Iran during the Qajar period, Babolsar: Mazandaran University Press.

Zargarinejad, G H. 1998. Constitutional Treatises. Tehran, second edition, Kavir publishing.

Ziba Kalam, S. 1993. Tradition and Modernity. Tehran, Rozaneh publishing.

Tabatabaei, S J. 1996. The decline of political thought in Iran. Tehran, Kavir publishing.

___________. 1988. Philosophical Introduction to the History of Political Thought in Iran. Tehran, Islamic Culture

Tabatabai, S J. 2007. A Reflection on Iran: Theory of Rule of Law in Iran. Tabriz, Sotoudeh Publications.

Enayat, H. 1999. Political Institutions and Thoughts in Iran. Tehran, Rozaneh publishing.

Eivazi, M R. 2010. Foundations of government and power building in Iran. Tehran, Payame Noor University publishing.

Feirihi, D. 2003. Political system and government in Islam. Tehran, Samat publishing.

Qaderi, H. 2000. Political Thoughts in Islam and Iran. Tehran, Samat publishing.

Kasravi, A. 1346. Constitutional History of Iran. Tehran, Amirkabir publishing.

Kadivar, J. 2000. The evolution of Shiite political discourse in Iran, Tehran, New Plan Publications.

The Constitution of the Constitutional Revolution.

Milani, A. 1999. Anti-modernism in Iran. Tehran, Atieh publishing.

Amendment of the Constitution of the Constitutional Revolution of Iran.

Movaseghi, A. 2008. Religion, society and government in Iran. Tehran, Publications of the Institute for Research and Development of Humanities.

Movaseghi, A. 2006. Renovation and Reform in Iran: From Perspective to Action. Tehran, Qoms Publishing.

Naeini, M H. 1982. Tanbih al-Ummah and Tanzih al-Mullah with introduction by Mahmoud T. leghani, Tehran, eighth edition Joint Stock Company Publishing.

Downloads

Published

2024-01-07

How to Cite

Barkhordari, A., & Metanat, M. R. (2024). Adaptability of Liberalism and Shiite Political Theory in the Thoughts of Allameh Naieni, A Theoretical Framework for the Iranian Constitutional Revolution. Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal, 11(1), 34–52. https://doi.org/10.14738/assrj.111.16158