Racial Differences in Auditory Hallucination Content and Attitudes: An Advancement in Cultural Psychiatry and Clinical Application of Social Determinants of Health
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14738/assrj.1010.15743Abstract
Background: Minimal prior literature compares the hallucinatory experiences of individuals from different racial backgrounds living within the same geographic area. Understanding differences of hallucinatory content and attitudes is essential to tailoring clinical advice for patients. We aim to investigate the differences in hallucinatory content and attitudes toward hallucinations for individuals of different races receiving care from the same academic institution. Methods: Cross-sectional study using an institutional database, randomly selected patient charts from 2008-2020. Inclusion criteria: age 10+ years, primary psychotic disorder, known race, documented auditory hallucination content. Excluded patients with hallucinations of non-psychiatric origin. Racial cohorts White, Black, Hispanic, and Asian each had n=50. Due to database limitations, Native American/Alaska Natives had n=8, Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander had n=7. Hallucination content and perception of symptoms (positive or negative) compared between cohorts using chi-square test of independence and multinomial regression. Findings: Blacks had the most hallucinations of violence, including police violence, and racism. Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islanders were most likely to have hallucinations of nature and medical violence. Hispanics had the most religious hallucinations. Asians had more derogatory hallucinations. Whites had more hallucinations of government violence. Native Hawaiians/Pacific Islanders were most likely to have a positive attitude towards hallucinations (positive:negative 3:4). Whites were least likely (positive:negative 1:11). Interpretation: Patients from different racial backgrounds in one geographic area experience auditory hallucinations differently. Appreciating these differences may improve trauma-informed care and cultural humility.
References
Blom JD, Mangoenkarso, E: Sexual Hallucinations in Schizophrenia Spectrum Disorders and Their Relation with Childhood Trauma. Frontiers in psychiatry 2018; 9:193.
Badcock JC, Larøi F, Kamp K, et al: Hallucinations in older adults: a practical review. Schizophrenia bulletin 2020; 46(6):1382-1395
Maijer K, Hayward M, Fernyhough C, et al: Hallucinations in children and adolescents: an updated review and practical recommendations for clinicians. Schizophrenia Bulletin 2019; 45(Supplement_1):S5-S23.
Kent G, Wahass S: The content and characteristics of auditory hallucinations in Saudi Arabia and the UK: a cross-cultural comparison. Acta psychiatrica Scandinavica 1996; 94(6):433–437.
Vermeiden M, Janssens M, Thewissen V, et al: Cultural differences in positive psychotic experiences assessed with the Community Assessment of Psychic Experiences-42 (CAPE-42): a comparison of student populations in the Netherlands, Nigeria and Norway. BMC psychiatry 2019; 19:1-15.
Suryani S, Welch A, Cox L: The phenomena of auditory hallucination as described by Indonesian people living with schizophrenia. Archives of psychiatric nursing 2013; 27(6):312–318.
Okulate GT, Jones OB; Auditory hallucinations in schizophrenic and affective disorder Nigerian patients: phenomenological comparison. Transcultural psychiatry 2013; 40(4):531–541.
Luhrmann TM, Padmavati R, Tharoor H, et al: Differences in voice-hearing experiences of people with psychosis in the U.S.A., India and Ghana: interview-based study. The British journal of psychiatry: the journal of mental science 2015; 206(1):41–44.
DeVylder JE, Oh HY, Yang LH, et al: Acculturative stress and psychotic-like experiences among Asian and Latino immigrants to the United States. Schizophrenia research 2013; 150:223-228.
Vanheusden K, Mulder CL., van der Ende J, et al: Associations between ethnicity and self-reported hallucinations in a population sample of young adults in The Netherlands. Psychological medicine 2018; 38(8):1095-1102.
Peach N, Alvarez-Jimenez M, Cropper SJ, et al: Trauma and the content of hallucinations and post-traumatic intrusions in first-episode psychosis. Psychology and psychotherapy 2021; 94 Suppl 2, 223–241.
Moernaut N, Vanheule S, Feyaerts J: Content Matters, a Qualitative Analysis of Verbal Hallucinations. Frontiers in psychology 2018; 9:1958. 215
Gannon M: Race Is a Social Construct, Scientists Argue: Racial categories are weak proxies for genetic diversity and need to be phased out. Scientific American 2016.
Vitetta L, Anton B, Cortizo F, et al: Mind-body medicine: stress and its impact on overall health and longevity. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 2005; 1057:492–505.
Loue S & Sajatovic M: Auditory and visual hallucinations in a sample of severely mentally ill Puerto Rican women: an examination of the cultural context. Mental Health, Religion and Culture 2008. 11(6):597-608.
Integrated Development for R, Inc. [RStudio], Version 1.1.456. Boston, MA, USA
Miranda J, McGuire TG, Williams DR, et al: Mental health in the context of health disparities. American Journal of Psychiatry 2008; 165(9); 1102-1108.
Williams DR & Williams-Morris R: Racism and mental health: the African American experience. Ethnicity & health 2000; 5(3-4):243–268.
GBD 2019 Police Violence US Subnational Collaborators. Fatal police violence by race and state in the USA, 1980-2019: a network meta-regression. Lancet 2021; 398(10307):1239–1255.
Yamada AM, Barrio C, Morrison SW, et al: Cross-ethnic evaluation of psychotic symptom content in hospitalized middle-aged and older adults. General Hospital Psychiatry 2006; 28(2):161-168.
Taylor P, Lopez MH, Martinez J: When Labels Don’t Fit: Hispanics and their View of Identity, V. Politics, Values and Religion. Pew Research Center 2012. https://www.pewresearch.org/hispanic/2012/04/04/vpolitics-values-and-religion/
Lerman S, Jung M, Arredondo EM, et al: Religiosity prevalence and its association with depression and anxiety symptoms among Hispanic/Latino adults. PloS one 2018; 13(2): e0185661.
Basile KC, Black MC, Simon TR, et al: The association between self-reported lifetime history of forced sexual intercourse and recent health-risk behaviors: findings from the 2003 National Youth Risk Behavior Survey. The Journal of adolescent health: official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine 2006; 39(5): 752.e1–752.e7527.
Fuligni AJ, Yip T, & Tseng V: The impact of family obligation on the daily activities and psychological wellbeing of Chinese American adolescents; Child development 2002; 73(1):302–314.
Juang LP & Cookston JT: A longitudinal study of family obligation and depressive symptoms among Chinese American adolescents. Journal of family psychology (journal of the Division of Family Psychology of the American Psychological Association 2009; 23(3):396–404.
Guo M, Kim S, & Dong X: Sense of Filial Obligation and Caregiving Burdens Among Chinese Immigrants in the United States. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 2019; 67(S3): S564–S570.
Hope BE & Hope JH: Native Hawaiian health in Hawaii: historical highlights. California journal of health promotion 2003; 1(Special Issue: Hawaii):1-9.
Iacono WG & Beiser M: Are males more likely than females to develop schizophrenia? The American journal of psychiatry 1992; 149(8):1070–1074.
Lopez L, Hart LH, & Katz MH: Racial and ethnic health disparities related to COVID-19. JAMA 2021;
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Emily Phu Thomas-Tran, Jane Thomas-Tran, Ivy Phu Tran, Rona J. Hu
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
