Influence of Cognitive Style and Gender on Secondary School Students’ Achievement in and Attitude to Chemistry
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14738/assrj.41.2585Abstract
The purpose of the study was to determine the influence of two major cognitive styles (Field Dependent and Field independent) and gender on students’ achievement in and attitude to chemistry.
A total of two hundred and eight (208) SSII chemistry students drawn from some selected secondary schools in three local government areas in Ibadan, Oyo state, Nigeria participated in the study. Three instruments were employed in this research. They are Cognitive Style Checklist (r=0.84), Chemistry Achievement Test(r=0.81) and Students’ Attitude to Chemistry Questionnaire(r=0.84)
This was a survey research. Four hypotheses were tested at 0.05 level of significance and data collected were analyzed using Descriptive Statistics and t-test.
The results showed that there was significant main difference between on field dependent and field independent students’ achievement in chemistry (t(1,207) = 5.173; P < 0.05]; students with field independent level of cognitive style obtained higher mean score of chemistry achievement (= 8.89) than those with field dependent level of cognitive style (= 8.19); there was no significant main difference between field dependent and field independent students’ attitude to chemistry [t(1,207) = 1.271; P>0.05] ; there was no significant main difference between male and female students’ achievement in chemistry [t(1,207) = .704; P>.05] but the female students obtained higher mean achievement score (= 98.64) than their male counterparts (= 98.28); there was significant main difference between male and female students’ attitude to chemistry [t(1,207) = 18.041; P<0.05]
Cognitive style can affect students’ achievement in chemistry and those of the field independent category perform better than those of the field dependent category; whereas, cognitive style has no influence on students’ attitude to chemistry. Even though, male and female students do not differ much in their achievement in chemistry, their attitude of the female students to chemistry is better than that of the male students
Therefore, it is recommended that teachers have adequate knowledge of the dominant cognitive style category in their classes as this could facilitate and ensure more meaningful learning as well as serve as guide for selection of teaching methods. In addition, chemistry teachers should make efforts in ensuring that chemistry classes are interesting and appealing to their male students.References
Achor, E. E., Kurumeh, S.M. and Orokpo, C. A. 2012 Gender Dimension in Predictors of Students’ Performance in MOCK-SSCE Practical and Theory Chemistry Examinations in some Secondary Schools in Nigeria. Education 2(2): pp 16-22
Adesoji, F.A and Olatunbosun, S.M. 2008. Student, Teachers and School environment factors as Determinants of Achievement in Senior Secondary School Chemistry in Oyo State, Nigeria. The Journal of International Social Research Vol 1(2) pp 13-34.
Adolpe F. 2002. A Cross-national Study of Classroom Environment and Attitudes among JSS students in Australia an in Indonesia. Doctoral Dissertation, Curtin Univ. of Technology.
Adu, E. O. 2002 Two Problem-Based Learning Strategies Quantitative Ability and Gender as Determinants Of Student Academic Achievement In Economics. An unpublished PhD thesis. University of Ibadan, Ibadan.
Alavi, H. R. and Hoseini, A. R. 2009 The Effect of Educational Factors on the Academic Performance of the University Students in Chemistry. Chemical Education Journal (CEJ) Vol 13:2
Appel, M. 2011. Stereotype threat impairs ability building. Effects on test preparation among women in Science and technology. European Journal of Social Psychology Vol 41, Issue 7 pp904 -913.
Bassey, S. W., Umoren, G. and Udida, L. A. (2013) Cognitive Styles, Secondary School Students’ Attitude and Academic Performance in Chemistry in Akwa Ibom State- Nigeria.www. hbcse.tifr.res.in/………./bassey
Bolger, N. and Kellaghan, T. 1990. Method of Measurement and Gender Differences in Scholastic Achievement. Journal of Educational Measurement Vol 27(2) pp 165 -174.
Bunce, D.M. and Gabel, D. 2002. Differential effects on the Achievement of Males and Female of teaching the Particulate nature of Chemistry Journal of Research in Science Teaching Vol. 39(10) pp 911 -927.
Calcateria, A., Antonetti, A. and Underwood, J. 2005. Cognitive Style, hypermedia navigation and Learning. Computer and Education Vol. 44 pp 441-457.
Idika, M.I. (2017). Influence of Congnitive Style and Gender on Secondary School Student’s Achievement in and Attitude to Chemistry. Advances in Caliskan, I.S. 2004. The Effect of Inquiry –based Chemistry Course on Students’ understanding of Atom Concept, Learning Approaches, Motivation, Self-Efficacy and Epistemological beliefs Published M.Sc Thesis in the Department of Secondary Science and Mathematics Education, The Middle East Technical University.
Chen, S.Y. and McCredie, R.D. 2004. Cognitive Modeling of Student Learning in web-based Instructional Programs. International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction. Vol.17(3) pp 375-402.
Davies, D.R. 2011. Children’s Performance as a function of Ser-typed labels. British Journal of Social Psychology Vol 25 (2) pp. 173 -195.
Deary, I.J 2007. Intelligence and Educational Achievement. Intelligence Vol. 35 (1) pp 13-21.
De-ture, M. 2004. Cognitive Style and Self-Efficacy. The American Journal of Distance Education. Vol. 18(1) pp.21-38.
Eraikhuemen, L. 2003. The Influence of Gender and School Location on Students’. Academic Achievement in Senior Secondary School Mathematics. Ife Journal of Theory and Research in Education Vol. 7(2) pp 99-112.
Guisande, M.A., Paramo, M.F., Tinajero, K.. and Almeida S.A. 2007. Field-dependence-independence (FDI) Cognitive Style: An analysis of attentional functioning Psicothema, Vol. 19(4) pp 572-577.
Ikejiaku, L.A. 2006. Psychology of Learning. Lagos.
Kirk, G. R. (2000) The Relationship of Attitudes towards science, cognitive styles and self-concept to achievement in chemistry at the secondary school level. DAI, 61(5), 1789-A Maghsudi, M. 2007. The Interaction Between Field Dependent/Independent Learning Styles and Learners’ Linguality in third Language Acquisition. Language in India Vol.7 pp. 1-16.
Marx and Klinger, D.A. 2000.Hierachical Linear Modeling of Student and School Effects on Academic Achievement Canadian Journal of Education. Vol. 25(1) pp 41-55.
Moe, A. 2009. Are males always better than females in mental rotation. Exploring a gender belief explanation Learning and Individual Differences. Vol 19(1) pp 21-27.
Nbina, J.B. 2012 Analysis of Poor Performance of Senior Secondary Students in Chemistry in Nigeria. African Research Review Vol 6(4) pp 324-334
O’Brein, T.P., Butler, S.M. and Bernold, L. E. 2001. Group Embedded Figures Test and acadaemic achievement in Engineering Education. Int. J. Engng Ed. Vol 47(1) pp 89-92
Okereke, C. 2011. Influence of Gender, School location and the use of play simulation on School Achievement in Chemistry. JORIND (9)1.
Ogunleye, B. O. 2011 “Team Pair Solo” Cooperative Learning and Personality type as Determinants of Students’ Achievement and Attitude to Chemistry. African Research Review. Vol 5(6) pp 259-276
Riding, R.J. and Sadler-Smith, E. 1997. Cognitive Style and Learning Strategies: Some Implications per training design International Journal of Training and Development Vol. (3) pp 199-208.
Salta, K. and Tzougraki, C. 2004. Attitudes towards Chemistry among 11th Grade Students’ in High Schools in Greece. Sci Ed Vol. 88(4) pp. 531-547.
Stoet, G. and Deary, D.C. 2012. Can Stereotype threat explain the gender gap in Mathematics performance and achievement? Review of General Psychology, Vol 16 (1) pp. 93 -102.
Tai, R.H., Sadler, P.M. and Loehr, J. F. 2005 Factors influencing Success in Introductory College Chemistry. J. Res Sci Teach 42: 987-1012
Vogel, S.A. 1990. Gender differences in Intelligence, Language, Visual-Motor Abilities, and Academic Achievement in Students with Learning Disabilities: A Review of the Literature Journal of Learning Disabilities.
Wachanga, S.W. and Mwangi, J.G. 2004. Effects of the Co-operative Class Experiment Teaching Method on Secondary School Students’ Chemistry Achievement in Kenya’s Nakuru District. International Education Journal Vol 5(1) pp 26-36.
Watson, A. 2010. The Problem of Boys’ Literacy Underachievement: Raising Some Questions Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy Vol 53 (5) pp 356 -361.
Welch, G.A. 2010. Using TOSRA to Assess High School Students’ Attitudes toward Science after Competing in the First Robotics Competition. EYMSTE Vol. 6(3) pp 187-197.
Wyss, R.(2002) Field Independent (Dependent Learning Styles and L2 Acquisition. The Weekly Column.
Zhang, L.F. 2004. Revisiting the Predictive Power of thinking styles for Academic Performance. Journal of Psychology: Interdisciplinary and Applied, Vol. 138 (4) pp 351 -370.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
