A Systematic Review of Digital Transformation and Smart Campus Adoption in Developing Countries
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14738/assrj.1306.11917Keywords:
Digital Transformation, Higher Education Institutions, socio-Technical Challenges, Developing Countries, Smart CampusAbstract
Higher education institutions (HEIs) are increasingly shaped by digital transformation. Innovative technologies are improving teaching, learning, and campus management, yet their adoption is uneven across contexts. In many developing countries, smart campus projects hold real promise for narrowing both educational and technological divides. At the same time, they encounter barriers that are deeply rooted in social and technical realities. To explore these challenges, the PRISMA method was applied to analyze 87 studies collected from Scopus, Web of Science, and IEEE databases. The review points to recurring obstacles, including weak stakeholder involvement, poor coordination in technology integration, and the lack of frameworks tailored to local needs. The study also found that much of the existing work overlooks important cultural factors, infrastructure limitations, and gaps in digital skills, all of which shape implementation outcomes. By bringing these issues together, the study provides practical direction for policymakers, university leaders, and campus planners. It argues for strategies that are sensitive to local conditions if smart campus adoption in developing regions is to be both effective and sustainable.
References
Gkrimpizi, T., V. Peristeras, and I. Magnisalis, Classification of Barriers to Digital Transformation in Higher Education Institutions: Systematic Literature Review. Education Sciences, 2023. 13(7): p. 746.
Malika, O. and E. Badr, The internationalization of higher education and labor market transformations study current and future digital capabilities. Multidisciplinary Science
Dehbi, A., et al., Education and smart technologies: Towards a new pedagogical paradigm. International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education, 2025. 14(1): p. 297-309.
Yusoff, T., et al., SMEs Sustainable Growth Model: The Role of Entrepreneurial Intention, Organizational Culture, and Networking Capabilities, in Integrating Big Data and IoT for Enhanced Decision-Making Systems in Business: Volume 2, R.K. Hamdan, Editor. 2026, Springer Nature Switzerland: Cham. p. 239-250.
Alenezi, M., S. Wardat, and M. Akour, The Need of Integrating Digital Education in Higher Education: Challenges and Opportunities. Sustainability, 2023. 15(6): p. 4782.
Mei, L., X. Feng, and F. Cavallaro, Evaluate and identify the competencies of the future workforce for digital technologies implementation in higher education. Journal of Innovation & Knowledge, 2023. 8(4): p. 100445.
Adarkwah, M.A., et al., Exploring the Transformative Journey of Academic Libraries in Africa before and after COVID-19 and in the Generative AI Era. The Journal of Academic Librarianship, 2024. 50(4): p. 102900.
Garcez, A., R. Silva, and M. Franco, The Hard Skills Bases in Digital Academic Entrepreneurship in Relation to Digital Transformation. Social Sciences, 2022. 11(5): p. 192.
Silva-da-Nóbrega, P.I., A.F. Chim-Miki, and M. Castillo-Palacio, A Smart Campus Framework: Challenges and Opportunities for Education Based on the Sustainable Development Goals.
Marks, A. and M. Al-Ali, Digital Transformation in Higher Education: A Framework for Maturity Assessment, in COVID-19 Challenges to University Information Technology Governance, M. Alaali, Editor. 2022, Springer International Publishing: Cham. p. 61-81.
Shenkoya, T. and E. Kim, Sustainability in Higher Education: Digital Transformation of the Fourth Industrial Revolution and Its Impact on Open Knowledge. Sustainability, 2023. 15(3): p.
Adarkwah, M.A., GenAI-Infused Adult Learning in the Digital Era: A Conceptual Framework for Higher Education. Adult Learning, 2025. 36(3): p. 149-161.
Okoye, K., et al., Towards teaching analytics: a contextual model for analysis of students’ evaluation of teaching through text mining and machine learning classification. Education and
Elayyan, S.R. and F.I. Al-Shizawi, Teachers' Perceptions of Integrating STEM in Omani Schools. Shanlax International Journal of Education, 2019. 8(1): p. 16-21. Page | 182 Scholar Publishing
Bygstad, B., et al., From dual digitalization to digital learning space: Exploring the digital transformation of higher education. Computers & Education, 2022. 182: p. 104463.
Ndibalema, P., Digital literacy gaps in promoting 21st century skills among students in higher education institutions in Sub-Saharan Africa: a systematic review. Cogent Education, 2025. 12(1): p. 2452085.
Li, G., et al., Assessment of digital transformation challenges for business model innovation in the context of higher education institutions using a decision support approach. Journal of Innovation & Knowledge, 2024. 9(3): p. 100527.
Lip, T.K., et al., Entrepreneurial Knowledge and Sustainable SMEs Performance: The Mediation Role of Strategic Opportunity Recognition. Advances in Social Sciences Research
Hu, Y., et al., Empowering Education: How the Smart Education Concept Improves English Learning and Bridges Urban–Rural Gaps—A Case Study in College A, in 2024 Yearbook Emerging Technologies in Learning, M.E. Auer and D. May, Editors. 2025, Springer Nature Switzerland: Cham. p. 439-463.
Fernandez, J.B., et al. Smart DCU Digital Twin: Towards Smarter Universities. in 2023 IEEE Smart World Congress (SWC). 2023.
Yin, X. and C. Ying, Digital Transformation of Higher Education: Trends, Innovation Models and Strategic Paths. Pakistan Journal of Life & Social Sciences, 2025. 23(1).
Correani, A., et al., Implementing a Digital Strategy: Learning from the Experience of Three Digital Transformation Projects. California Management Review, 2020. 62(4): p. 37-56.
Zickafoose, A., et al., Barriers and Challenges Affecting Quality Education (Sustainable Development Goal #4) in Sub-Saharan Africa by 2030. Sustainability, 2024. 16(7): p. 2657.
Raqee, A., et al., Influence of Risk Reduction and Hedging on Project Management: Internal Control Mediator in Iraqi SMEs Construction, in Tech Fusion in Business and Society : Harnessing Big Data, IoT, and Sustainability in Business: Volume 2, R.K. Hamdan, Editor. 2025, Springer Nature Switzerland: Cham. p. 873-899.
Al-Zubaidi, R., et al., Market Orientation and SMEs Performance: Unraveling the Mediating Effects of Innovation Capability Amidst Environmental Uncertainty, in Tech Fusion in Business and Society : Harnessing Big Data, IoT, and Sustainability in Business: Volume 2, R.K.
Mohamed Hashim, M.A., I. Tlemsani, and R. Matthews, Higher education strategy in digital transformation. Education and Information Technologies, 2022. 27(3): p. 3171-3195.
Homer, S.T., P.W. Chuen, and C. Chuah, Sustainable development education through student engagement: findings from a comprehensive study. Quality & Quantity, 2026. 60(1): p. 1-31.
Abdulsamad, A., et al., Entrepreneurial Orientation and Innovation Capabilities as Drivers of Sustainable Innovation Performance: A Conceptual Framework for SMEs, in Tech Fusion in Business and Society : Harnessing Big Data, IoT, and Sustainability in Business: Volume 2, R.K.
Milhem, M., et al., The Impact of Organizational Justice and Organizational Values on Reducing Work Stress Among Security Personnel at Gulf International Bank, in Integrating Artificial Intelligence, Security for Environmental and Business Sustainability : Volume 1, A.
Khalilov, T., Strategic Planning-Based Management Practices In Higher Education Institution. Pakistan Journal of Life & Social Sciences, 2025. 23(1).
Ouyang, F., L. Zheng, and P. Jiao, Artificial intelligence in online higher education: A systematic review of empirical research from 2011 to 2020. Education and Information Technologies, 2022. 27(6): p. 7893-7925.
Chen, J., et al. Semi-supervised Campus Network Intrusion Detection Based on Knowledge Distillation. in 2023 International Joint Conference on Neural Networks (IJCNN). 2023. Page | 183 Scholar Publishing
Alotaibi, N.S., The Significance of Digital Learning for Sustainable Development in the Post-COVID19 World in Saudi Arabia’s Higher Education Institutions. Sustainability, 2022. 14(23): p.
Truong, T.C. and Q.B. Diep, Technological Spotlights of Digital Transformation in Tertiary Education. IEEE Access, 2023. 11: p. 40954-40966.
Sneesl, R., et al., Examining IoT-Based Smart Campus Adoption Model: An Investigation Using Two-Stage Analysis Comprising Structural Equation Modelling and Artificial Neural Network. IEEE Access, 2023. 11: p. 125995-126026.
Salas-Pilco, S.Z. and Y. Yang, Artificial intelligence applications in Latin American higher education: a systematic review. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 2022. 19(1): p. 21.
Singun, A., Jr., Unveiling the barriers to digital transformation in higher education institutions: a systematic literature review. Discover Education, 2025. 4(1): p. 37.
Kelder, J.-A., et al., Enhancing digital productivity and capability in higher education through authentic leader behaviors: A cross-cultural structural equation model. Education and
Abd Al-Aziz, A.-r., et al., Building Tourist Loyalty through Service Quality: Mediating Role of Tourist Satisfaction Insights from Emerging Tourism Market. Journal of Business and Social Review in Emerging Economies, 2025. 11(4).
Al-Refaei, A.A.-A., et al., A Conceptual Framework for the Impact of Entrepreneurial Leadership on Innovation Work Behavior and Sustainable Innovation Performance, in Entrepreneurship Innovation and Education for Performance Improvement, S.A. Salman and A. Bhaumik, Editors. 2024, IGI Global: Hershey, PA, USA. p. 577-598.
Bakar, M.R.A., A Systematic Review of Smart Campus Initiatives in Transforming Higher Education Institutions. Journal of Information and Knowledge Management, 2025. 15(SI2): p.
Bravo-Jaico, J., et al., Model for assessing the maturity level of digital transformation in higher education institutions: a theoretical-methodological approach. Frontiers in Education, 2025. Volume 10 - 2025.
Rahmadi, I.F., Research on Digital Transformation in Higher Education: Present Concerns and Future Endeavours. TechTrends, 2024. 68(4): p. 647-660.
Zou, Y., et al., Digital learning in the 21st century: trends, challenges, and innovations in technology integration. Frontiers in Education, 2025. Volume 10 - 2025.
Polin, K., et al., Reframing Smart Campus Assessment for the Global South: Insights from Papua New Guinea. Sustainability, 2025. 17(14): p. 6369.
Al-Sharif, A.M., et al., The role of innovation capability in the relationship between entrepreneurial leadership and innovation performance in the SMEs service industry. Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal, 2023. 10(1): p. 264-278.
Al-Sharif, A., et al., Effects of Innovation Capability and Environmental Dynamism on the Relationship between Entrepreneurial Leadership and Innovation Performance in the SMEs Service Industry. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 2023. 13(10).
Tyagi, S., V. Gupta, and V. Mehndiratta, Building Smart Campuses: Integrating AI in Higher Education, in Recent Trends in Artificial Intelligence Towards a Smart World: Applications in Industries and Sectors, R. Arya, et al., Editors. 2024, Springer Nature Singapore: Singapore. p.
Tang, J., P. Huang, and S. Yan, Digital transformation in higher education: logical framework, practical dilemmas, and implementation approaches. Frontiers in Psychology, 2025. Volume 16 - 2025. Page | 184 Scholar Publishing
Wong, J.M.S., W.K.W. Tang, and K.C. Li, Digital transformation in higher education: tertiary students' perspectives on online learning and its implications for the future. International Journal of Innovation and Learning, 2025. 37(5): p. 1-18.
Makazhe, E.C. and T.C. Maramura. The Role of Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR) Technologies in Achieving Sustainable Development Goals. in Corporate Practices: Policies, Methodologies, and Insights in Organizational Management. 2024. Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore.
Trevisan, L.V., et al., Digital transformation towards sustainability in higher education: stateof-the-art and future research insights. Environment, Development and Sustainability, 2024. 26(2): p. 2789-2810.
Raja Santhi, A. and P. Muthuswamy, Industry 5.0 or industry 4.0S? Introduction to industry 4.0 and a peek into the prospective industry 5.0 technologies. International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM), 2023. 17(2): p. 947-979.
Sneesl, R., et al., Revising Technology Adoption Factors for IoT-Based Smart Campuses: A Systematic Review. Sustainability, 2022. 14(8): p. 4840.
Zhang, Y., et al., Digital Transition Framework for Higher Education in AI-Assisted Engineering Teaching. Science & Education, 2025. 34(2): p. 933-954.
Zhang, Y., et al., A Systematic Review on Technologies and Applications in Smart Campus: A Human-Centered Case Study. IEEE Access, 2022. 10: p. 16134-16149.
Mohammadzadeh, Z., et al., Smart city healthcare delivery innovations: a systematic review of essential technologies and indicators for developing nations. BMC Health Services Research, 2023. 23(1): p. 1180.
Choi, W. and S. Kim, Curriculum Development of EdTech Class Using 3D Modeling Software for University Students in the Republic of Korea. Sustainability, 2023. 15(24): p. 16605.
Mohamed Elshaiekh, N., et al., Enhancing Educational Systems on Creating Job Opportunities by Promoting Knowledge-Based Economy in the Sultanate of Oman. Qubahan Academic
Negi, S., H.J. Karyamsetty, and B.A. Fida, Developing Graduates for the Fourth Industrial Revolution and Oman Vision 2040: The Role of Business Schools in Shaping the Future Workforce. Sage Open, 2026. 16(1): p. 21582440251410308.
Mualla, W. and K.J. Mualla, Digital Transformation in Higher Education: Challenges and Opportunities for Developing Countries, in Higher Education in the Arab World: Digital Transformation, A. Badran, et al., Editors. 2024, Springer Nature Switzerland: Cham. p. 211-
Benavides, L.M.C., et al., Digital Transformation in Higher Education Institutions: A Systematic Literature Review. Sensors, 2020. 20(11): p. 3291.
Alotaibi, N.S. and A.H. Alshehri, Prospers and Obstacles in Using Artificial Intelligence in Saudi Arabia Higher Education Institutions—The Potential of AI-Based Learning Outcomes.
Alotaibi, N.S., The Impact of AI and LMS Integration on the Future of Higher Education: Opportunities, Challenges, and Strategies for Transformation. Sustainability, 2024. 16(23): p.
Mijač, T., M. Jadrić, and M. Ćukušić, Measuring the success of information systems in higher education – a systematic review. Education and Information Technologies, 2024. 29(14): p.
Plekhanov, D., H. Franke, and T.H. Netland, Digital transformation: A review and research agenda. European Management Journal, 2023. 41(6): p. 821-844.
Kitchenham, B., et al., Systematic literature reviews in software engineering–a systematic literature review. Information and software technology, 2009. 51(1): p. 7-15. Page | 185 Scholar Publishing
Aldahmashi, A. and A. Abdulsamad, The Added Value of Applying Governance, Risk, and Compliance (GRC) in the Healthcare Sector: A Literature Review. Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal, 2026. 13(04): p. 84-92.
Aldahmashi, A. and A. Abdulsamad, From Risk Management to Healthcare Quality: The Role of Leadership Effectiveness-A Narrative Review. Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal, 2026. 13(05): p. 16-35.
Asamoah, K.O., et al., A probabilistic reliable linguistic model for blockchain-based student information management system assessment. Applied Soft Computing, 2024. 159: p. 111645.
Yıldırım, N. and D. Tunçalp, A Policy Design Framework on the Roles of S&T Universities in Innovation Ecosystems: Integrating Stakeholders’ Voices for Industry 4.0. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 2023. 70(7): p. 2608-2625.
Anggadwita, G., N. Indarti, and V. Ratten, Changes in Indonesian private universities educational practices in the post COVID-19 environment. The International Journal of Management Education, 2024. 22(1): p. 100905.
Xie, Y., et al., Multimodal data visualization method for digital twin campus construction. International Journal of Digital Earth, 2024. 17(1): p. 2431624.
Mishra, A.R., et al., An integrated picture fuzzy standard deviation and pivot pairwise assessment method for assessing the drivers of digital transformation in higher education institutions. Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence, 2024. 133: p. 108508.
Chen, X., et al., Blockchain in smart education: Contributors, collaborations, applications and research topics. Education and Information Technologies, 2023. 28(4): p. 4597-4627.
Zheng, L., et al., Evolutionary machine learning builds smart education big data platform: Data-driven higher education. Applied Soft Computing, 2023. 136: p. 110114.
Wang, K., et al., Evaluate the drivers for digital transformation in higher education institutions in the era of industry 4.0 based on decision-making method. Journal of Innovation & Knowledge, 2023. 8(3): p. 100364.
Guo, T. and F. Xia, Student Behavior Pattern Mining and Analysis: Towards Smart Campuses, in Proceedings of the Sixteenth ACM International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining. 2023, Association for Computing Machinery: Singapore, Singapore. p. 1305–1306.
Wang, M., et al., Exploring college students' risk perception and acceptance intention of facial recognition technology in China. Telematics and Informatics, 2024. 95: p. 102193.
Mohd Rahim, N.I., et al., AI-Based Chatbots Adoption Model for Higher-Education Institutions: A Hybrid PLS-SEM-Neural Network Modelling Approach. Sustainability, 2022. 14(19): p. 12726.
Arshad, S., et al., Hierarchical, Attribute and Hash-Based Naming and Forwarding Aided Smart Campus of Things. Sustainability, 2023. 15(23): p. 16361.
Abdalzaher, M.S., et al., Toward Secured IoT-Based Smart Systems Using Machine Learning. IEEE Access, 2023. 11: p. 20827-20841.
dos Santos Sá, J., et al., Multimodal urban mobility solutions for a smart campus using artificial neural networks for route determination and an algorithm for arrival time prediction. Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence, 2024. 137: p. 109074.
Zarpellon, B.O., et al., Design and Implementation of a Smart Campus Flexible Internet of Things Architecture on a Brazilian University. IEEE Access, 2024. 12: p. 113705-113725.
Lu, Y., X. Hu, and J. Li, Smart campus: The deep integration of machine vision and physical education. International Journal of Maritime Engineering, 2024. 1(1): p. 163-174.
Ferreira, A., et al. Internet of Things for Smart Education: A Systematic Literature Review. in 2024 IEEE International Conference on Advanced Learning Technologies (ICALT). 2024.
Carlos-Mancilla, M.A., et al., Educational Mechatronics and Internet of Things: A Case Study on Dynamic Systems Using MEIoT Weather Station. Sensors, 2021. 21(1): p. 181. Page | 186 Scholar Publishing
Llerena-Izquierdo, J., et al., Innovations in Introductory Programming Education: The Role of AI with Google Colab and Gemini. Education Sciences, 2024. 14(12): p. 1330.
Al-Zahrani, A.M. and T.M. Alasmari, Exploring the impact of artificial intelligence on higher education: The dynamics of ethical, social, and educational implications. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 2024. 11(1): p. 912.
Wang, Q., L. Kong, and L. Cui. A Complete Protection, Certification and Traceability System for Academic Degrees Based on Collaborative Storage on and Off the Chain. in 2024 27th International Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work in Design (CSCWD). 2024.
Tleubayeva, A., et al. Systemic approach to optimizing natural language processing technologies in Astana IT University's admissions process. in 2024 IEEE 4th International Conference on Smart Information Systems and Technologies (SIST). 2024.
Rana, M.M., et al., Assessing AI adoption in developing country academia: A trust and privacyaugmented UTAUT framework. Heliyon, 2024. 10(18).
Ding, Z., J. Mei, and K. Zheng. An MQTT-Based Student Condition Monitoring System for Physical Education. in 2023 IEEE International Conference on Advanced Learning Technologies (ICALT). 2023.
Berdnikova, L.F., et al. Controlling as a Tool to Reduce the Risks of Smart University in the Digital Economy. in Smart Education and e-Learning 2021. 2021. Singapore: Springer Singapore.
Essel, H.B., et al., The impact of a virtual teaching assistant (chatbot) on students' learning in Ghanaian higher education. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 2022. 19(1): p. 57.
Xiao, J., et al., Towards a Trusted and Unified Consortium-Blockchain-Based Data Sharing Infrastructure for Open Learning—TolFob Architecture and Implementation. Sustainability, 2021. 13(24): p. 14069.
Dong, R., et al. Smart Campus Construction based on Telecom Operators Big Data. in 2023 IEEE 22nd International Conference on Trust, Security and Privacy in Computing and Communications (TrustCom). 2023.
Ferreira, D., et al., Planning and Optimization of Software-Defined and Virtualized IoT Gateway Deployment for Smart Campuses. Sensors, 2022. 22(13): p. 4710.
Jokhan, A., et al., Increased Digital Resource Consumption in Higher Educational Institutions and the Artificial Intelligence Role in Informing Decisions Related to Student Performance.
Muñoz, J., et al., Path Loss Characterization in an Outdoor Corridor Environment for IoT-5G in a Smart Campus University at 850 MHz and 3.5 GHz Frequency Bands. Sensors, 2023. 23(22): p. 9237.
Jain, S. and D. Chawla. A Smart Education Model for Future Learning and Teaching Using IoT. in Information and Communication Technology for Intelligent Systems. 2021. Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore.
Dabis, A. and C. Csáki, AI and ethics: Investigating the first policy responses of higher education institutions to the challenge of generative AI. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 2024. 11(1): p. 1006.
Chivu, R.-G., et al., The Role of Blockchain Technologies in the Sustainable Development of Students’ Learning Process. Sustainability, 2022. 14(3): p. 1406.
Razzaq, M.A., et al., Hybrid auto-scaled service-cloud-based predictive workload modeling and analysis for smart campus system. IEEE Access, 2021. 9: p. 42081-42089.
de Moraes, P.A., F. Pisani, and J.F. Borin, Smart University: A pathway for advancing Sustainable Development Goals. Internet of Things, 2024. 27: p. 101246. Page | 187 Scholar Publishing
Ayanwale, M.A. and R.R. Molefi, Exploring intention of undergraduate students to embrace chatbots: from the vantage point of Lesotho. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 2024. 21(1): p. 20.
Cruz, H.A.O., et al., Methodology for LoRa Gateway Placement Based on Bio-Inspired Algorithmsfor a Smart Campus in Wooded Area. Sensors, 2022. 22(17): p. 6492.
da Silva Júnior, E., et al. Optimizing Academic Pairings in Smart Campuses: A Recommendation System for Academic Communities. in CSEDU (1). 2024.
Aspilcueta Narvaez, A., et al. Smart Campus IoT Guidance System for Visitors Based on Bayesian Filters. in Proceedings of the 5th Brazilian Technology Symposium. 2021. Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Zhou, C., Integration of modern technologies in higher education on the example of artificial intelligence use. Education and Information Technologies, 2023. 28(4): p. 3893-3910.
Ruan, Z., et al., Automatic depression detection among higher education students based on DeepFM. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement, 2024. 73: p. 1-10.
Bjelobaba, G., et al., Blockchain Technologies and Digitalization in Function of Student Work Evaluation. Sustainability, 2022. 14(9): p. 5333.
Sáez, P., J. Morales, and F. Silva-Aravena. Digital Skills in Higher Education: Strategies Adopted by Universities to Promote their Development in Students and Professors. in 2024 43rd International Conference of the Chilean Computer Science Society (SCCC). 2024.
Son-Turan, S., Fostering Equality in Education: The Blockchain Business Model for Higher Education (BBM-HE). Sustainability, 2022. 14(5): p. 2955.
Garg, A., et al., Blockchain-based online education content ranking. Education and Page | 188
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
