Supreme Court Reforms: The Challenge of Change
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14738/abr.129.17540Keywords:
United States Supreme Court, reform, term limits, Chevron deference, presidential immunity, abortion, voting rights, campaign financesAbstract
This article discusses proposals for “reform” of the United States Supreme Court based on the background and facts of five important and controversial Supreme Court cases dealing with campaign finance, voting rights, abortion rights, the administrative state, and finally, and perhaps most critically, presidential immunity for alleged criminal acts.
References
Adler, J.H. (2020). An argument against Supreme Court term-limits. reason.com (October 14, 2020). https://reason.com/volokh/2020/10/14/an-argument-against-supreme-court-term-limits/.
Ahearn, J. & Milov-Cordoba, M. (2024). Alito piles on reasons for congress to act on Supreme Court ethics. The Brennan Center for Justice (May 24, 2024). https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/alitopiles-reasons-congress-act-supreme-court-ethics.
Ang, D. (2019). Do 40-year old facts still matter? Long-run effects of federal oversight under the Voting Rights Act. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 11(3): 1-53.
Bannon, A. (2023). It’s time for Supreme Court term limits. The Brennan Center For Justice (June 20, 2023). https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/its-time-supreme-court-term-limits.
Bannon, A. & Keith, D. (2022). What research shows about the importance of Supreme Court diversity. The Brennan Center for Justice (February 1, 2022). https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysisopinion/what-research-shows-about-importance-supreme-court-diversity
Bannon, A. & Milov-Cordoba, M. (2023). Supreme Court term limits. The Brennan Center for Justice (June 20, 2023). https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/policy-solutions/supreme-court-term-limits.
Beckel, M. (2016). What is political ‘dark money’ – and is it bad? Center for Public Integrity (June 20, 2016). https://medium.com/@Publici/what-is-political-dark-money-and-is-it-bad-c7c2cab54020.
Becket, S. (2024). What was Trump convicted of? Details on the 34 counts and his guilty verdict. CBS News (June 3, 2024. https://www.cbsnews.com/trump-charges-conviction-guilty-verdict/
Bentsen, H.L. (2019). Dissent, legitimacy, and public support for court decisions: Evidence from a survey-based experiment. Law and Society Review 53(2): 588-610.
Biden, J. (2024). Opinion: My plan to reform the Supreme Court and ensure no president is above the law. Washington Post (July 29, 2024). https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/07/21.
Biskupic, J. (2021). In the shadows: Why the Supreme Court’s lack of transparency may cost it in the long run. cnn.com (September 2, 2021). https://www.cnn.com/2021/09/01/politics/transparency-analysis-supreme-court-abortion/index.html.
Blazina C. & Gramlich, J. (2022). 5 facts about the Supreme Court. Pewresearch.org (February 25, 2022). https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2022/02/25/5-facts-about-the-supreme-court/.
Blum, A.T., Greenberg, M.J., & Saylor, L.J. (2022). Supreme Court signals move away from judicial deference to administrative agencies. National Law Review XIV (220). https://www.natlawreview.com/article/supremecourt-signals-move-away-judicial-deference-to-administrative-agencies.
Brennan Center for Justice (2019). Americans are united against partisan gerrymandering. Brennancenterforjustice.org (March 15, 2019). https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/researchreports/americans-are-united-against-partisan-gerrymandering.
Buchanan, M.J. (2020). The need for Supreme Court term limits. Center for American Progress (August 3, 2020). https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/cap-term-limits.pdf.
Cahill-O’Callaghan, R. (2020). Values in the Supreme Court: Decisions, division and diversity. Oxford, U.K.: Hart Publishing.
Calabresi, S.G. & Lindgren, J. (2006). Term limits for the Supreme Court: Life tenure reconsidered. Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 29: 770-877.
Chung, A. (2023). The Supreme court is infected with the “most damaging” human bias. politico.com (August 30, 2023). http://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/08/30/supreme-court-partisanship-unpopular-00113401. Citizens United (Web page) (2014). Citizens United.org. https://www.citizensunited.org (last accessed August 14, 2024).
Congressional Research Service (2021). The modes of constitutional analysis: Judicial precedent (Part 4) (LSB1067). Congressional Research Service (December 30, 2021). https://crsreports.congress.gov
Congressional Research Service (2023). The Supreme Court adopts a code of conduct (LSB 11111078). Congressional Research Service (November 17, 2023). https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/LSB/11078.
Conway, M. (2024). Biden’s Supreme Court term limit proposal is too little— but maybe not too late. MSNBC.com. https://www.msnbc.com/en/-us/news/politics/biden-s-supreme-court-term-limit-proposalis-too-little-but-mavbe-not-too-late/ar-BBir7f2P.
Devins, N. & Baum, L. (2017). Split definitive: How party polarization turned the Supreme Court into a partisan court. Supreme Court Review (University of Chicago Law Review) 2016: 301-365.
Dobkin, R. (2024). Joe Biden’s Supreme Court reform plan backed by majority of Republicans. MSN.com (April 11, 2024). https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/joe-biden-s-supreme-court-reform-plan-backed-bymajority-of-republicans/.
Elliott, D., & McCammon, S. (2023). A year after the Dobbs abortion ruling, the impact nationwide has been dramatic. NPR.org (June 23, 2023). https://www.npr.org/2023/06/23/1183931379/a-year-after-the-dobbsabortion-ruling-the-impact-nationwide-has-been-dramatic.
Erskine, E. (2022). Term limits for justices gain new attention, but prospects for passage remain dim. SCOTUSblog (August 16, 2022). https://www.scotusblog.com/2022/08/term-limits-for-justices-gain-newattention-but-prospects-for-passage-remain-dim/.
Fidler, D.P. (2018). The Supreme Court adapts constitutional law to address constitutional change. Council on Foreign Relations (July 11, 2018). https://www.cfr.org/blog/supreme-court-adapts-constitutional-law-addresstechnological-change
Frost, A. (2013). Judicial ethics and Supreme Court exceptionalism. Georgetown Journal of Legal Ethics 26: 443-479.
Garrison, J. (2024). What to know about President Biden’s election-year proposals to change the Supreme Court. USA Today. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/what-to-know-about-president-bidens-election-yearproposals-to-change-the-supreme-court/ar-BB1qPzxA.
Germer, M. (2022). Opinions on judicial reform: A review of the 2021 Supreme Court commission. RStreet.org (April 27, 2022). https://rstreet.org/people/matt-germer/.
Gersh, A. & Totenberg, N. (2023). The Supreme Court adopts first-ever code of ethics. NPR (November 13, 2023). https://www.npr.org/2023/11/13/1212708142/supreme-court-ethics-code.
Gomez, J. (2024). Supreme Court term limits are unconstitutional. Christian Post (August 6, 2024). https://www.christianpost.com/voices/supreme-court-term-limits-are-unconstitutioal.html.
Griffin, K., Orden. E., & Seligman, L. (2024). Could a president really order SEAL team 6 to kill a rival? It seems so. Politico (July 2, 2024). https://www.snopes.com/news/2024/07/01/scotus-ruling-seal-team/.
Griffing, A. (2024). Kagan pulls back the curtain on Supreme Court ethics reform, drops plan to enforce code of conduct. MSN.com. https://www.msn.com/en-us/tv/news/kagan-pulls-back-the-curtain-on-supreme-courtethics-reform-drops-plan-to-enforce-code-of-conduct/ar-BB1qQb7L.
Hayes, H. (2022). Diversity on the bench: Why it matters in a polarized Supreme Court. American Bar Association (August 17, 2022). https://www.americanbar.org/groups/diversity/women/publications/perspectives/2022/august/diversitythe-bench-why-it-matters-a-polarized-supreme-court.
Hemel, D. (2021). Can structural changes fix the Supreme Court? Journal of Economic Perspectives 35: 118-142.
Herr, J. (2023). Pros and cons of enacting term limits on Supreme Court justices. ACE-USA.org (April 11, 2023). https://ace-usa.org/blog/research/research-democratic-governance/pros-and-cons-of-enactingsupreme-court-term-limits/.
Howe, A. (2022). Supreme Court curtails EPA’s authority to fight climate change. SCOTUSblog.com (June 30, 2022). https://www.scotusblog.com/2022/06/supreme-court-curtails-epas-authority-to-fight-climate-change/.
Hudson, J. (2012). How Justice Souter almost left the Supreme Court in a blaze of glory. The Atlantic (May 14, 2012). https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2012/05/how-justice-souter-almost-left-supreme-courtblaze-glory/328163/.
Hunter, R.J. & Alexander-Becker, P. (2000). Constitutional cases and controversies of the United States Supreme Court, 2000 term. Journal of Law and Family Studies (University of Utah) 3(1): 1-21.
Hunter, R.J. & Alexander-Becker, P. (2001). “The most important thing we do is not doing”: Changing concepts in constitutional law: Judicial activism v. judicial restraint. Business Law Review 34: 87-100.
Hunter, R.J. & Lozada, H.R. (2010). A nomination of a Supreme Court justice: The incorporation doctrine revisited. Oklahoma City Law Review 35: 365-385.
Hunter, R.J., Shannon, J.H., & Lozada, H.R. (2022a). To paraphrase: “What’s Griswold have to do with it?”: Perhaps holding the key to a decision by the United States Supreme Court. Journal of Business and Social Science Review 3(2): 1-13.
Hunter, R.J., Shannon, J.H., & Lozada, H.R. (2022b). A primer on the United States Supreme Court: An indispensable party in creating a legal cannon. Global Journal of Political Science and Administration 10(3): 11-26.
Jefferson, W.B. & McGregor, R.V. (2021). Supreme Court justices shouldn’t get lifetime appointments. It’s time to impose term limits. NBCNews.com (July 15, 2021). https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/supreme-courtjustices-shouldn-t-get-lifetime appointments-it-s-ncna1273882.
Jones, J.M. (2022). Confidence in U.S. Supreme Court sinks to historic low. gallup.com (June 23, 2022). https://news.gallup.com/poll/394103/confidence-supreme-court-sinks-historic-low.aspx.
Jurist News (2013). The McCain-Feingold Act. Jurist.org (July 20, 2013). https://www.jurist.org/archives/feature/us-campaign-finance-and-the-mccain-feingold-act/.
Kamalu, N.C & Kamalu, H.O. (2024). From Roe to Dobbs: How the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) muddled through a half a century of women’s reproductive rights/ abortion from enshrinement to dissolution. Sumerianz Journal of Social Science 7(3): 21-30.
Kurtzleben, D. (2022). What we know (and don’t know) about how abortion affected the midterms. NPR.org (November 25, 2022). https://www.npr.org/2022/11/25/1139040227/abortion-midterm-elections-2022-republicans-democrats-roe-dobbs.
Las Vegas Review-Journal (2024). Editorial: A middle ground on presidential immunity. Las Vegas Review-Journal (July 1, 2024). https://www.reviewjournal.com/opinion/editorials/editorial-a-middle-ground-onpresidential-immunity-3078845/.
LAWS.com (2023). Supreme Courts criticisms overview. laws.com (November 7, 2023). https://constitution.laws.com/supreme-court-criticisms/supreme-courts-criticisms
Leuchtenburg, W.E. (2005). When Franklin Roosevelt clashed with the Supreme Court – and lost. Smithsonian Magazine (May 2005). https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/when-franklin-roosevelt-clashed-with-thesupreme-court-and-lost-78497994/.
Liebmann, T. (2024). Introduction: Accountability and the future of the Supreme Court. Hofstra Law Review 52: 551-556.
Liptak, A. (2009). Sotomayor faces heavy workload of complex cases. New York Times (August 6, 2009). https://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/07/us/politics/07scotus.html.
Littlefield, A. (2021). The Christian legal army behind the ban on abortion in Mississippi. The Nation (November 30, 2021). https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/alliance-defending-freedom-dobbs/.
Madhani, A. & Long, C. (2024). Biden’s decries ‘extremism’ on Supreme Court, details plan for term limits, ethics code for justices. ABCNews.com (July 29, 2024). https://www.usnews.com/news/politics/articles/2024-07-29/biden-unveils-plan-for-supreme-court-changessays-us-stands-at-breach-as-public-confidence-sinks.
Manchester, J. (2018). Americans tend to be in favor of term limits for most institutions, says pollster. The Hill (September 27, 2018). https://thehill.com/hilltv/what-americans-thinking-408781-americans-tend-to-be-infavor-of-term-limits-for-most
Marcum, A. (2020). An argument against Supreme Court term-limits. RStreet.org (October 15, 2020). https://www.rstreet.org/commentary/an-argument-against-supreme-court-term-limits/.
Marley, P. (2024). Supreme Court’s Trump immunity ruling poses risk for democracy, experts say. The Washington Post (July 1, 2024). https://www.memeorandum.com/240702/p22#a240702p22.
Martinez, A. (2024). The arguments against setting term limits for Supreme Court justices. NPR.org (August 5, 2024). https://www.npr.org/2024/08/05/nx-s1-5060213/the-arguments-against-setting-term-limits-forsupreme-court-justices
Millhiser, I. (2022). The Supreme Court’s big EPA decision is a massive power grab by the justices. Vox.com (June 30, 2022). https://www.vox.com/2022/6/30/23189610/supreme-court-epa-west-virginia-clean-power-planmajor-questions-john-roberts.
Muller, D.T. (2024). 2020’s ‘fake elector’ schemes will be harder to try in 2024—but not impossible. The Conversation (June 19, 2024). https://theconversation.com/2020s-fake-elector-schemes-will-be-harder-to-tryin-2024-but-not-impossible-229094.
Nazzaro, M. (2024). John Dean says Nixon ‘would have survived’ Watergate under immunity ruling. The Hill (July 2, 2024). https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/4750581-supreme-court-immunity-nixon/.
New York Times (2024). Read the Supreme Court’s ethics rule. New York Times (November 13, 2023). https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/11/13/us/supreme-court-ethics-rules.html.
Open Secrets (2022). More money, less transparency: A decade under Citizens United. Open Secrets (January 4, 2022). https://www.opensecrets.org/news/reports/a-decade-under-citizens-united-dark-money.
Orstein, N.J. & Mann, T.E. (2002). Myths and realities about the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002. Brookings (May 7, 2002). https://www.brookings.edu/articles/myths-and-realities-about-the-bipartisancampaign-reform-act-of-2002/.
Parlatore, T.C. (2024). Opinion: The presidential immunity ruling is good for Trump – and for Biden, too. CNN.com (July 4, 2024). https://www.cnn.com/2024/07/03/opinions/trump-biden-scotus-presidentialimmunity-parlatore/index.html
Polantz, K, Rabinowitz, H., & Cole, D. (2024). Judge dismisses classified documents case against Donald Trump; Special counsel’s office to appeal. CNN Politics (July 15, 2024). https://edition.cnn.com/2024/07/15/politics/classified-documents-case-trump-dismissed-aileencannon/index.html.
Post, R.C. (2014). Citizens divided: Campaign finance reform and the constitution. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
Regnier, M. (2022). The ongoing consequences of Citizens United v. FCC and influence of money in elections. Legal Research Club of the University of Alabama (March 22, 2022). https://legalresearchclub.ua.edu/blog/2022/03/22/the-ongoing-consequences-of-citizens-united-v-fec-andinfluence-of-money-in-elections/.
Richey, W. (2009). Was ‘Hillary: The movie’ wrongly censored? Christian Science Monitor (March 24, 2009). https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Justice/2009/0324/p02s01-usju.html
Rivkin, D.B. & Foley, E.P. (2024). America depends on presidential immunity. Wall Street Journal (July 1, 2024). https://davidbrivkin.com/america-depends-on-presidential-immunity/.
Ross, W.G. (2024). A critique of Biden’s proposal for Supreme Court term limits. jurist.org (August 8, 2024). https://www.jurist.org/commentary/2024/08/a-critique-of-bides-proposal-for-supreme-court-termlimits/.
Savage, C. (2024). Highlights of the Supreme Court ruling on presidential immunity. New York Times (July 1, 2024). https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/01/us/politics/supreme-court-immunity-ruling-highlights.html.
Segal, J.A., Timpone, R.J., & Howard, R.M. (2000). Buyer beware? Presidential success through Supreme Court appointments. Political Research Quarterly 53(3): 557-573.
Showalter, M., Rasche, S.A., & Bryan, R.A. (2022). Five administrative law takeaways from recent Supreme Court decisions. National Law Review XIV (220). https://www.natlawreview.com/article/five-administrative-lawtakeaways-recent-supreme-court-decisions.
Silverleib, A. (2010). Gloves come off after Obama rips Supreme Court ruling. CNN.com (January 28, 2010). https://www.cnn.com/2010/POLITICS/01/28/alito.obama.sotu/index.html.
Sitaraman, G. & Epps, D. (2021). The future of Supreme Court reform. Harvard Law Review 134: 398-414.
Stanford Report (2024). The impact of overturning the Chevron decision. Stanford Report (June 28, 2021). https://news.stanford.edu/stories/2024/06/stanfords-deborah-sivas-on-scotus-loper-decision-overturningchevrons-40-years-of-precedent-and-its-impact-on-environmental-law
Stepansky, J. (2024). Biden is pushing for Supreme Court reform. Is it ‘dead on arrival’? aljazeera.com (August 2, 2024). https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/8/2/biden-is-pushing-for-supreme-court-reform-is-it-dead-onarrival.
Sullum, J. 92024). Trump’s criticism of Biden’s Supreme Court reforms is hard to take seriously. Chicago Sun Times (July 31, 2024). https://chicago.suntimes.com/columnists/2024/07/31/trump-criticism-bidens-supreme-court-reforms-ishard-to-take-seriously.
Supreme Court Historical Society (2024). FDR & the court packing controversy. Supremecourthistory.org. https://supremecourthistory.org/schs-historical-documentaries/fdr-courtpacking-controversy-full-script (last accessed August 14, 2024).
Tang, A. (2023). The Supreme Court is infected with the ‘most dangerous’ human bias. Politico (August 30, 2023). https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/08/30/supreme-court-partisanship-unpopular-00113401.
Truax, C. (2024). Out of order: Who will keep the Supreme Court accountable if it won’t police itself? The Hill (May 24, 2024). https://thehill.com/opinion/judiciary/4682142-supreme-court-accountable-recusal-alito-flag/.
U.S. Commission on Civil Rights (2025). Assessment of minority voting rights access. United States Commission on Civil Rights. https://www.usccr.gov/reports/2018/assessment-minority-voting-rights-access-united-states.
Vasilogambros, M. (2018). Polling places remain a target ahead of November elections. Stateline.org (Pew Research) (September 4, 2018). https://stateline.org/2018/09/04/polling-places-remain-a-target-ahead-ofnovember-elections/.
Vladeck, S. (2024). The shadow docket: How the Supreme Court uses stealth rulings to amass power and undermine the Republic. New York: Basic Books.
Walker, C. (2024). Two-thirds of Americans say Supreme Court justices should have term limits. truthout.org (August 8, 2024) https://truthout.org/articles/two-thirds-of-americans-say-supreme-courtjustices-should-have-term-limits.
Wang, H.L. (2023). Restoring the Voting Rights Act is still on this Alabama Democrat’s agenda. NPR.org (September 19, 2023). https://www.linkedin.com/posts/hansilowang_restoring-the-voting-rights-act-is-stillactivity-7109873550064263169-j-GO.
White House (2021). Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court of the United States. Whitehouse.gov (December 7, 2021). https://www.whitehouse.gov/pcscotus/final-report/.
Wilkinson, J.H. (2021). Opinion: Supreme Court term limits wouldn’t solve anything. Washington Post (October 17, 2021). https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/10/18/.
Williams, J. (2024). Biden’s Supreme Court reform is serious business. The Hill (August 5, 2024). https://thehill.com/opinion/columnists/juan-williams/4807797-president-biden-warns-supremecourt/.
Witt, J.F. (2023). The Showdown: FDR vs. the Supreme Court. The Nation (July 10/17,2023). https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/court-packing-supreme-court-roosevelt.
Wooding, V. (2024). Reform and future trends in administrative law: Emerging issues, challenges, and opportunities. Counsel Stack (June 22, 2024). https://blog.counselstack.com/reform-and-future-trends-inadministrative-law-emerging-issues-challenges-and-opportunities/.
Zurcher, A., Tawfik, N., Lambert, L., & Epstein, K. (2024). The Chevron deference, and why it mattered. BBC.com (June 28, 2024). https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c51/ywrq45qo.538.com (2024). Latest polls. Do Americans approve or disapprove of the Supreme Court? fivethirtyeight.com (August 7, 2024) (last accessed August 24, 2024). https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/polls/approval/supreme-court/.
Cases Cited Austin v. Michigan Chamber of Commerce (1990). 494 U.S. 652. (United States Supreme Court).
Buckley v. Valeo (1976). 424 U.S. 1 (United States Supreme Court).
Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc. (1984). 467 U.S. 837 (United States Supreme Court).
Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization (2022). 597 U.S. 215 (United States Supreme Court).
FEC v. Wisconsin Right to Life, Inc. (2007). 551 U.S. 449. (United States Supreme Court).
First National Bank v. Bellotti (1978). 435 U.S. 765 (United States Supreme Court).
Griswold v. Connecticut (1975). 381 U.S. 479 (United States Supreme Court).
Lawrence v. Texas (2003). 539 U.S. 558 (United States Supreme Court).
Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo (2024). 603 U.S. (United States Supreme Court).
McConnell v. FEC (2003). 540 U.S. 93 (United States Supreme Court).
McCutcheon v. FEC (2014). 572 U.S. 185 (United States Supreme Court).
Nixon v. Fitzgerald (1982). 457 U.S. 731 (United States Supreme Court).
NLRB v. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corporation (1937). 301 U.S. 1 (United States Supreme Court).
Obergefell v. Hodges (2015). 576 U.S. 644 (United States Supreme Court).
Palko v. Connecticut (1935). 302 U.S. 319 (United States Supreme Court).
Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992). 505 U.S. 833 (United States Supreme Court).
Roe v Wade (1973). 410 U.S. 113 (United States Supreme Court).
Rucho v. Common Cause (2019). 588 U.S. 684 (United States Supreme Court).
Shelby County v. Holder (2013). 570 U.S. 529 (United States Supreme Court).
SpeechNow.org v. FEC (2010). 599 F.3d 686 (en banc). (United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit).
Thompson v. Trump (2021). No. 1:21-CV-00400 (United States District Court for the District of Columbia).
Trump v. United States (2024). 603 U.S. (United States Supreme Court).
United States v. Fitzgerald (1982). 457 U.S. 731 (United States Supreme Court).
United States v. Nixon (1974). 418 U.S. 683 (United States Supreme Court).
Weinberger v. Romero-Barcelo (1982). 456 U.S. 305 (United States Supreme Court).
West Virginia v. Environmental Protection Agency (2022). 597 U.S. 697 (United States Supreme Court).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Richard J. Hunter, John H. Shannon, Héctor R. Lozada
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
