What Obstacles Stands in the Way of the Achievement of Socialism
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14738/abr.1111.15651Keywords:
JEL Class. P, J54, B14, P2Abstract
The aim of this paper is to show that a system of democratically managed firms is the model of socialism best tailored to human nature. From the author’s perspective, considering that the retention of markets in such a system allows selfish drives of individuals to act themselves out to the full, its establishment would come up against fewer obstacles than those standing in the way of the creation of a centrally planned one. An additional thesis advanced in the paper is that that the process leading to the advent of such a system can be looked upon as a socialist revolution consistent with the principles of Darwinian evolutionism.
References
AA. VV., 1969, Marx vivo, Mondadori, Milan.
AA. VV., 1970, Marxismo ed etica, Ital. transl. of ‘Marxism and Ethics’, Feltrinelli, Milan.
Althusser L., Balibar E., 1965, Leggere il Capitale, Ital. transl. Of ‘Reading Capital’, Milan, Feltrinelli, 1968.
Althusser L., 1965a, Per Marx, Ital. transl., Rome, Editori Riuniti, 1969.
Althusser L., 1965b, L’oggetto del capitale, in Althusser & Balibar 1965.
Althusser L., 1969 and 1995, Sur la reproduction, Paris, Presses universitaires de France.
Althusser L., 1972, Risposta a John Louis (An Answer to John Louis), in Althusser 2005.
Althusser L., 2005, I marxisti non parlano mai al vento, ed. by L. Tomasetta, Mimesis, Milan.
Ball T., Farr J., 1984, eds., After Marx, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Bataille G., 1996, Il limite dell’utile, Ital. transl. of ‘La limite de l’util’, Adelphi Edizioni, Milan, 2000.
Bellofiore R., 2007, Da Marx a Marx?, maifestolibri, Rome.
Bernstein E., 1901, Zur Geschichte und Theorie des Sozialismus, Akademischer Verlag für Soziale Wissenschaft, Berlin. intriguing anecdote. “Your friend, he writes (op. cit. pp. 111-12), has to undertake a trip of which he is obviously afraid. You know that he is afraid, his wife knows it, everyone else knows it, but he does not know it. He claims one day that he does not feel well, the next day that there is no need to make the trip, the day after that that there are better ways to achieve the same result without travelling, then the next day that your persistence in reminding him of the trip is an attempt to force him; and since he does not want to be forced, he just won't make the trip, and so on, until he will say that it is now too late to go on the trip, anyway, and that hence there is no use in thinking any further about it. … What has happened? The real motivation for not wanting to go is fear ... and this fear is unconscious.” And due to the attitudes of mind that that Freud terms ‘resistances’, it is all but easy to find a cure that will bring the unconscious to the surface. These reflections suggest that the transition to socialism might be greatly expedited by employment-boosting State policies. 27 In point of fact, there is general agreement that even individual cooperative firms often find it difficult to gain a firm foothold (see, inter alia, Zamagni 2017, p. -39).
Bloom S.F., 1943, Man of His Century: a Reconsideration of the Historical Significance of Karl Marx, in Wood 1988.
Bowles S., Gintis H., 1986, Democracy and Capitalism, Basic Books, New York.
Carver T., 1984, Marxism as Method, in Ball & Farr 1984.
Commons J. R., 1924, Legal Foundations of Capitalism, University of Wisconsin Press, Milwaukee, 1968.
Copeland M. A., 1931, Economic Theory and the Natural Science Point of View, in American Economic Review, vol. 21, no. 1, March.
Copeland M. A., 1936, Common’s Institutionalism in Relation to the Problem of Social Evolution and Economic Planning, in Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 50, no. 2, February.
Cornu A., 1948, Karl Marx e il pensiero moderno, Ital. transl. of ‘Karl Marx et la pensée moderne’ Einaudi, Turin, 1949.
Cornu A., 1955, Marx e Engels dal liberalismo al comunismo, Ital. transl. of ‘Karl Marx et Friedrich Engels’, Feltrinelli, Milan, 1962.
Dawkins R., 1989, Il gene egoista, Ital. transl. of ‘The Selfish Gene’, Oscar Mondadori, Milan, 1995.
Di Siena G., 1972, Biologia, darwinismo sociale e marxismo, in Supplement to no. 4 of Critica marxista, 1972.
Donnaruma C., Partyka N., 2012, Challenging the Presumption in Favor of Markets, in Review of Radical Political Economics, vol. 44, no.1.
Dugger W. M., 2003, David Hamilton: a Radical Institutionalist, in Journal of Economic Issues, vol. XXXVII, no. 1, March.
Engels F., 1845, Due discorsi a Eberfeld, in Marx-Engels, Opere complete, vol. IV.
Finelli R., 2007, Un marxismo ‘senza Capitale’, in Bellofiore 2007.
Fromm E., 1961, Marx’s Concept of Man, New York, Frederick Ungar.
Fromm E., 1962, Marx e Freud, Ital. transl., Il Saggiatore, Milano, 1968.
Frowen S. F., 1997, ed., Hayek: Economist and Social Philosopher, MacMillan, London.
Gintis H., 1976, The Nature of Labor Exchange and the Theory of Capitalistic Production, in Review of Radical Political Economics, vol. 8, no. 2.
Gobetti P.,1924, La rivoluzione liberale, Einaudi, Turin, 1965.
Gramsci A., 1919-1920, L’Ordine nuovo, Einaudi, Turin, 1954.
Gramsci A., 1975, Quaderni del carcere, ed. by V. Gerratana, vol. IV, Einaudi, Turin.
Gustafsson B., 1974, Capitalismo e socialismo nel pensiero di Bernstein, in Istituto Giangiacomo Feltrinelli 1974.
Hahn F.H., 1993, Il futuro del capitalismo: segni premonitori, in Rivista milanese di economia, no. 46, April-June.
Hamilton D., 1999, Evolutionary Economics; a Study of Change in Economic Thought, Transaction Publishers,
Jossa, B. (2023). What Obstacles Stands in the Way of the Achievement of Socialism. Archives of Business Research, 11(11). 22-39. New Brunswick.
Hamilton D., 2003, Technology Is Not Ancillary: The Dramatic and Prosaic in Economic Theory, in Journal of Economic Issues, vol. XXXVII, no. 1, March.
Haupt G., 1978, Marx e il marxismo, in Hobsbawm et alii 1978-82, vol. I.
Hayek F. A., 1982, Legge, legislazione e libertà, Ital. Transl. of ’Recht, Gesetz und Freiheit’, Il Saggiatore, Milano, 1986.
Hobsbawm E. J., Haupt G., Marek F., Ragionieri E., Strada V, Vivanti C., 1978-1982, eds, Storia del marxismo, 5 vols, Turin, Einaudi.
Hodgson G.M., 2003, Darwinism and Institutional Economics, in Journal of Economic Issues, vol. 37, no. 1, March.
Istituto Giangiacomo Feltrinelli, 1974, Storia del marxismo contemporaneo, Feltrinelli, Milan.
Jossa B., 1998, Mercato, socialismo e autogestione, Carocci, Rome.
Jossa B., 2005, Marx, Marxism and the Cooperative Movement, in Cambridge Journal of Economics, no. 1.
Jossa B., 2010, Esiste un’alternativa al capitalismo?, manifestolibri, Rome.
Jossa B., 2012c, A System of Self-managed Firms as a New Perspective on Marxism, in Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 36, no. 4, July.
Jossa B., 2012a, Cooperative Firms as a New Production Mode, in Review of Political Economy, vol. 23, July.
Jossa B., 2012b, Alienation and the Self-Managed Firm System, in The Review of Radical Political Economics, vol. 36, no. 4, July.
Jossa B., 2014, A System of Cooperative firms as a New Production Mode, Routledge, London.
Kant I., 1798, Se il genere umano sia in costante progresso verso il meglio, in Kant 1956.
Kant I., 1956, Scritti politici e di filosofia della storia e del diritto, UTET, Turin.
Karsz S., 1974, Teoria e politica: Louis Althusser, Ital. transl. of ‘Theorie et politique: Louis Althusser’, Dedalo Libri, Bari, 1976.
Keynes J.M., 1979, The Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes, vol. XXIX; The General Theory and After: a Supplement, Macmillan, London.
Khalil E. L., Boulding K. E., 1996, eds, Evolution Order and Complexity, Routledge, London Leube K.R., 1988, Social Policy: Hayek and Schmoller Compared, in International Journal of Social Economics, no. 9-10-11.
Lowit T., 1962, Marx et le mouvement cooperatif, in Cahiers de l’institut de science èconomique appliquée, ni. 129, September.
Luporini C., 1966, Realtà e storicità: economia e dialettica nel marxismo, in Luporini 1974.
Luporini C., 1974, Dialettica e materialismo, Editori Riuniti, Rome.
Marcuse H., 1969, Un riesame del concetto di rivoluzione, in AA.VV.1969.
Markus G., 1966, Marxismo e antropologia, Ital. transl. of’ Marxizmus és „antropológia”, Liguori Editore, Naples 1978.
Marshall A., 1889, Cooperation, in Marshall 1925.
Marshall A., 1890, Principles of Economics, Macmillan, London.
Marshall A., 1925, Memorials of Alfred Marshall, ed. by A. C. Pigou, Macmillan, London, Marx K., Engels F., 1845-1846, L’ideologia tedesca, Ital. transl. of ‘Die deutsche Ideologie’, 3rd editn., Editori Riuniti, Rome, 1969.
Marx K., Engels F., Opere complete, Editori Riuniti, Rome. Marx K., 1844, Manoscritti economico-filosofici del 1844, Einaudi, Turin 1968.
Marx K., 1845, Tesi su Feuerbach, in Marx-Engels, Opere complete, vol. V.
Marx K., 1857-58, Lineamenti fondamentali della critica dell’economia politica, La Nuova Italia, Florence 1970.
Marx K., 1859, Outline of the Critique of Political Economy, in Marx-Engels, Collected Works, vol. 29.
Marx K., 1864, Inaugural Address of the Working Men’s International Association, in Marx-Engels, Collected Works, vol. 20.
Marx K., Engels F., 1975-2001, Collected Works, vols 1-49, Lawrence and Wishart, London.
Mill J. S., 1871, Principi di economia politica, 3rd editn, Ital. transl. of ‘Principles of Political Economy’, Turin 1953.
Miller E. S., 2002, Economics in a Public Interest: Remark upon Receiving the Veblen-Commons Award, in Journal of Economic Issues, vol. XXXVI, no. 2, June.
Miller E. S., 2003, Evolution and Stasis: The Institutional Economics of David Hamilton, in Journal of Economic Issues, vol. XXXVII, no. 1, March.
Mondolfo R., 1909, Feuerbach e Marx, in Mondolfo 1968.
Mondolfo R., 1962, La concezione dell’uomo in Marx, in Mondolfo 1968.
Mondolfo R., 1968, Umanismo di Marx. Studi filosofici, 1908-1966, Einaudi.
Orfei R., 1970, Marxismo e umanismo, Rome, Coines Edizioni.
Piff P., et al., 2012, Reply to Francis in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, no. 109, 25.
Prestipino G., 1973, Natura e società, Editori Riuniti, Rome.
Ratner C., 2013, Cooperation, Community, and Co-Ops in a Global Era, Springer Publishers.
Rawls J., 1971, A Theory of Justice, Cambridge Mass, Harvard Economic Press Rawls J., 2000, Lezioni di storia della filosofia morale, Ital. transl. of ’Lectures on the History of Moral
Jossa, B. (2023). What Obstacles Stands in the Way of the Achievement of Socialism. Archives of Business Research, 11(11). 22-39.
Philosophy, Feltrinelli, Milan, 2004.
Rifkin J., 2009, Civiltà ed empatia, Ital. transl. of ‘The Empathic Civilization’, Mondadori, Milan, 2011.
Scalfari E, 2012, La passione per l’etica, Mondadori, Milan.
Scalfari E., 1995, Alla ricerca della morale perduta, in Scalfari 2012.
Schaff A., Séve L., 1975, Marxismo e umanesimo, Dedalo libri, Bari.
Schaff A., 1971, Sulla traduzione francese della VI tesi di Marx su Feuerbach, Ital. transl. of ‘On the French translation of Marx’s 6th Thesis on Feuerbach), in Schaff & Séve 1975.
Schumpeter J. A., 1950, The March into Socialism, in American Economic Review, vol. LX, no. 2.
Screpanti E., 2007, Democrazia radicale e lotta di classe : alcune precisazioni, in Il Ponte, ybk LXIII, nos 8-9.
Sève L., 2004, Penser avec Marx aujourd’hui, vol. I, Marx et nous, La Dispute, Paris.
Singer P., 1980, Marx, Oxford University Press, London.
Solari S., 2012, The ‘Practical Reason’ of Reformers: Proudhon vs. Istitutionalism, in Journal of Economic Issues, vol. XLVI, no. 1.
Streit M. E., 1997, Constitutional Ignorance, Spontaneous Order and Rule-Orientation: Hayekian Paradigms from a Policy Perspective, in Frowen 1997.
Therborn G., 1971, Critica e rivoluzione; la Scuola di Francoforte, Ital. transl., Laterza, Bari, 1972.
Vanek J., 1971b, “The Basic Theory of Financing of Participatory Firms”, reprinted in Vanek, 1977
Vanek J., 1971c, The Participatory Economy: An Evolutionary Hypothesis on a Strategy for Development, Cornell University Press, Ithaca.
Vanek J., 1977, The Labor Managed Economy: Essays by J. Vanek, Cornell University Press, Ithaca.
Veblen T. B., 1964, What Veblen Thought, Augustus M. Kelley, New York.
Vorländer C, 1911, Kant e Marx, in AA.VV. 1970.
Ward B. N., 1958, The Firm in Illyria; Market Syndicalism, in American Economic Review, vol. 48, no. 4, September.
Wood J. C., 1988, ed., Karl Marx’s Economics: Critical Assessments, New South Wales, Croom Helm.
Zamagni V., 2017, Attualità dell’impresa cooperativa, in Nuova secondaria, no. 3, November.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Bruno Jossa
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
