Criteria For Evaluating Environmental Sustainability Performance of Building Projects: A Review
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14738/tecs.122.16768Keywords:
environmental sustainability, performance evaluation, criteria, building projects, bibliometric review, sustainable constructionAbstract
This study aimed at identifying the criteria for evaluating environmental sustainability performance (ESP) of building projects and examining the research developments and performance (‘hot’ themes, status quo, and research gaps) in the research domain. A literature search was conducted using the Scopus search engine, augmented by Google Scholar, to identify 59 relevant articles for analysis. A bibliometric analysis was undertaken with the use of VOSViewer to better understand the broad literature on ESP of building projects. Content analysis allowed for a systematic review of the selected articles to reveal the criteria for evaluating ESP of building projects in the literature. Among the criteria identified include energy, emissions, waste, materials, water, and land/site. These were grouped into Environmental Management, Resource Consumption and Protection, Design, Policies and Certification, and Preservation, for better appreciation and holistic understanding of building project evaluation criteria. The research “hot” themes were ‘life-cycle assessment’, ‘sustainability in building projects’, ‘environmental assessment’ and ‘multi-criteria decision-making’, and the research status quo was ‘life-cycle assessment’, ‘analytical hierarchy process‘, ‘key performance indicators’, and ‘building information modeling’. Research gaps identified from the study include ‘Performance evaluation’, ‘Buildings’, ‘Key performance indicators’. Grouping ESP evaluation criteria offers a holistic understanding of building project evaluation criteria, enhancing understanding and application in the industry.
References
Sanmi, O. and Ayodeji, O. (2019),” Criteria for measuring Sustainable Construction Project Performance in Nigeria”, In IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, Vol.331, No.1, p.012020).
Contrada, F., Kindinis, A., Caron, J.F. and Gobin, C. (2019), “An early-design stage assessment method based on constructibility for building performance evaluation”, In IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, Vol.609, No.7, p.072070). IOP Publishing.
McKinsey Global Institute (2017) https://www.mckinsey.com/constructionsector
Lima, L., Trindade, E., Alencar, L., Alencar, M. and Silva, L. (2021),” Sustainability in the construction industry: A systematic review of the literature”, Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol.289, p.125730.
Yang, H., Yeung, J.F., Chan, A.P., Chiang, Y.H. and Chan, D.W. (2010),” A critical review of performance measurement in construction”, Journal of Facilities Management, Vol.8, No.4, pp.269-284.
Oyewobi, L.O., Windapo, A.O. and Rotimi, J.O.B. (2015),"Measuring strategic performance in construction companies: a proposed integrated model”, Journal of Facilities Management, Vol.13, No.2, pp.109-132.
Gunduz, M. and Elsherbeny, H.A. (2020),” Construction Contract Administration Performance Assessment Tool by Using a Fuzzy Structural Equation Model”, Sustainability, Vol.12, p523.
Tseng, C.-H., Chang, K.-H., and Chen, H.-W. (2019),” Strategic orientation, environmental innovation capability, and environmental sustainability performance: The case of Taiwanese suppliers”, Sustainability, Vol.11, p112.
Adams, C.A., Muir, S. and Hoque, Z. (2014), “Measurement of sustainability performance in the public sector”, Sustainability Accounting, Management and Policy Journal.
Oke, A., Aghimien, D., Aigbavboa, C. and Musenga, C. (2019), “Drivers of sustainable construction practices in the Zambian construction industry”, Energy Procedia, Vol.158, pp.3246-3252.
Kiani Mavi, R., Gengatharen, D., Kiani Mavi, N., Hughes, R., Campbell, A. and Yates, R. (2021), “Sustainability in construction projects: A systematic literature review”, Sustainability, Vol.13, p.1932.
Marcelino-Sádaba, S., González-Jaen, L.F. and Pérez-Ezcurdia, A. (2015),” Using project management as a way to sustainability. From a comprehensive review to a framework definition”, J. Clean. Prod., Vol.99, pp1–16.
Presley, A. and Meade, L. (2010),” Benchmarking for sustainability: an application to the sustainable construction industry”, Benchmarking: An International Journal, Vol.17, No.3, pp.435-451.
Adabre, M.A. and Chan, A.P. (2020), “Towards a sustainability assessment model for affordable housing projects: The perspective of professionals in Ghana”, Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, Vol27,
Kamali, M., Hewage, K. and Milani, A.S. (2018), “Life cycle sustainability performance assessment framework for residential modular buildings: Aggregated sustainability indices”, Building and Environment, Vol.138, pp.21-41.
Nagel, S., Hiss, S., Woschnack, D. and Teufel, B. (2017),” Between Efficiency and Resilience: The Classification of Companies According to their Sustainability Performance”, Historical Social Research, Vol.42, No.1p159.
Haapio, A. (2012), “Towards sustainable urban communities”, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, Vol.32,
Vega, R. (2015),” Methodology for the sustainability assessment of facades”. In Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Engineering Sustainability (Vol.168, No.5, pp.204-215). Thomas Telford Ltd.
Osei-Kyei, R. and Chan, A.P. (2017), “Developing a project success index for public–private partnership projects in developing countries”, Journal of Infrastructure Systems, Vol.23, No.4, p. 04017028.
Awuzie, B.O., Monyane, T.G., Koker, C.D. and Aigbavboa, C.O. (2021), “Evaluation of Factors Influencing Environmental Sustainability Performance of Construction Projects in South Africa”, Sustainability and Climate Change, Vol.14, No.2, pp.122-132.
Afful, A.E., Ayarkwa, J., Acquah, G.K.K. and Osei-Asibey, D. (2021), “Enablers of incorporating indoor environmental quality (IEQ) principles into buildings”, Smart and Sustainable Built Environment.
Kukah, A.S.K., Owusu-Manu, D.-G. and Edwards, D. (2022),"Critical review of emotional intelligence research studies in the construction industry”, Journal of Engineering, Design and Technology.
Zhao, X., Zuo, J., Wu, G. and Huang, C. (2019),” A bibliometric review of green building research 2000–2016”, Architectural Science Review, Vol.62, No.1, pp.74-88.
Archambault, É., Campbell, D., Gingras, Y. and Larivière, V. (2009), “Comparing bibliometric statistics obtained from the Web of Science and Scopus”, Journal of the American society for information science and technology,
Van Eck, N.J. and Waltman, L. (2018),” VOSviewer: A computer program for bibliometric mapping”. In Proceedings of the 12th International Conference of the International Society for Scientometrics and Informetrics, Vol.2, pp.886-897.
Afful, A.E., Ayarkwa, J., Acquah, G.K.K., Osei-Asibey, D. and Assibey, A.A.D.O. (2022), “Barriers to incorporation of indoor environmental quality (IEQ) principles into building designs”, Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management.
Zhong, B., Wu, H., Li, H., Sepasgozar, S., Luo, H. and He, L. (2019), “A scientometric analysis and critical review of construction related ontology research”, Automation in Construction, Vol.101, No.2019, pp. 17-31.
Chen, W., Liu, W., Geng, Y., Brown, M.T., Gao, C., Wu, R. (2017), “Recent progress on emergy research: a bibliometric analysis”, Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev.Vol.73, pp1051-1060. 104
Rowlands, I. (2018),” What are we measuring? Refocusing on some fundamentals in the age of desktop bibliometrics”, FEMS Microbiology letters, Vol.365, No.8.
Zupic, I. and Čater, T. (2015),” Bibliometric methods in management and organization”, Organizational research methods, Vol.18, No.3, pp.429-472.
Kraus, M. and Senitkova, I.J. (2019),” Life-Cycle Assessment of Sustainable Foundation Systems of Buildings”, In IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and EngineeringVol.603, No.5, p.052078.
Sameer, H., and Bringezu, S. (2019),” Life cycle input indicators of material resource use for enhancing sustainability assessment schemes of buildings”, Journal of Building Engineering, Vol.21, pp230–242.
Ding, G.K. (2008), “Sustainable construction: The role of environmental assessment tools”, J. Environ. Manag., Vol.86, pp.451–464.
Alsanad, S. (2015), “Awareness, Drivers, Actions, and Barriers of Sustainable Construction in Kuwait”, Procedia Engineering, Vol.118, pp969–983.
Bernardi, E., Carlucci, S., Cornaro, C. and Bohne, R.A. (2017), “An analysis of the most adopted rating systems for assessing the environmental impact of buildings”, Sustainability, Vol.9, No.7, p.1226.
Tam, V.W., Le, K.N. and Zeng, S.X. (2015),” Green evaluation systems for project sustainability”. In Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Waste and Resource Management, Vol.168, No.4, pp.177-185.
Navarro, I.J., Martí, J.V. and Yepes, V. (2022),” Group analytic network process for the sustainability assessment of bridges near shore. High Performance and Optimum Design of Structures and Materials”, Encompassing Shock and Impact Loading, Vol.209, p.143.
Tseng, M.L. and Chiu, A.S. (2013),” Evaluating firm's green supply chain management in linguistic preferences”, Journal of cleaner production, Vol.40, pp.22-31.
Mushtaha, E., Shamsuzzaman, M., Abdouli, S. A., Hamdan, S., and Soares, T.G. (2020),” Application of the analytic hierarchy process to developing sustainability criteria and assessing heritage and modern buildings in the UAE”, Architectural Engineering and Design Management, Vol.16, No.5, pp329–355.
Rajabi, S., El-Sayegh, S. and Romdhane, L. (2022),” Identification and assessment of sustainability performance
Owusu-Manu, D.G., Babon-Ayeng, P., Kissi, E., Edwards, D.J., Okyere-Antwi, D. and Elgohary, H. (2022),” Green construction and environmental performance: an assessment framework”, Smart and Sustainable Built Environment.
Buckman, A.H., Mayfield, M. and BMBeck, S. (2014), “What is a smart building?” Smart and Sustainable Built Environment, Vol.3, No.2, pp.92-109.
Ng, S.T., Chen, Y. and Wong, J.M. (2013),” Variability of building environmental assessment tools on evaluating carbon emissions”, Environmental impact assessment review, Vol.38, pp.131-141.
Lindberg, C.F., Tan, S., Yan, J. and Starfelt, F. (2015),” Key performance indicators improve industrial performance”, Energy procedia, Vol.75, pp.1785-1790.
Maslesa, E., Jensen, P.A. and Birkved, M. (2018),” Indicators for quantifying environmental building performance: A systematic literature review”, Journal of building engineering, Vol.19, pp.552-560.
El Hawary, M. and Marzouk, M. (2021), “Predicting buildings life cycle sustainability behaviour using system dynamics”, Architectural Engineering and Design Management, pp.1-17.
Asgari, S. and Noorzai, E (2021), “Improving the effectiveness and interaction between building information modeling and life cycle assessment”, Architectural Engineering and Design Management, pp.1-17.
Ryberg, M.W., Ohms, P.K., Møller, E. and Lading, T., 2021. Comparative life cycle assessment of four buildings in Greenland. Building and Environment, 204, p.108130.
Lin, S.H., Zhao, X., Wu, J., Liang, F., Li, J.H., Lai, R.J., Hsieh, J.C. and Tzeng, G.H. (2022),” An evaluation framework for developing green infrastructure by using a new hybrid multiple attribute decision-making model for promoting environmental sustainability”, Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, Vol.75, p.100909.
Reddy, A.S., Kumar, P.R. and Raj, P.A. (2019),” Developing a material sustainable performance score (MSPS) to select an alternative cementitious material”, Cement Wapno Beton, Vol.24, No.1, pp.68-79.
McGinley, O., Moran, P. and Goggins, J. (2022),” An Assessment of the Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) of Energy Efficient Retrofits to Existing Residential Buildings”, Energies, Vol.15, No.1, p.334.
Janjua, S., Sarker, P. and Biswas, W., 2019. A review of residential buildings’ sustainability performance using a life cycle assessment approach. Journal of Sustainability Research, 1(1), pp.1-29.
Osama A.B. Hassan, (2016),"An integrated approach to assessing the sustainability of buildings", Journal of Engineering, Design and Technology, Vol. 14 Iss 4 pp.
Marzouk, M., Abdelbasset, I. and Al-Gahtani, K. (2021),” Evaluating building systems energy performance superiority and inferiority ranking”, Journal of Environmental Informatics, Vol.38, No.1, pp.56-67.
Lim, Y.W., Chong, H.Y., Ling, P.C. and Tan, C.S. (2021),” Greening existing buildings through Building Information Modelling: A review of the recent development”, Building and Environment, Vol.200, p.107924.
Tupenaite, L., Lill, I., Geipele, I. and Naimaviciene, J. (2017),” Ranking of sustainability indicators for assessment of the new housing development projects: Case of the Baltic States”, Resources, Vol.6, No.4, p.55.
Supino, S., Malandrino, O., Testa, M. and Sica, D. (2015),” Sustainability in the EU cement industry: the Italian and German experiences”, Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol.112, pp.430-442.
Nabeeh, N.A., Abdel-Basset, M. and Soliman, G. (2021),” A model for evaluating green credit rating and its impact on sustainability performance”, Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol.280, p.124299.
Sahlol, D.G., Elbeltagi, E., Elzoughiby, M. and Abd-Elrahman, M. (2021),” Sustainable building materials assessment and selection using system dynamics”, Journal of Building Engineering, Vol.35, p.101978.
Phoya, S. (2018),” Sustainable construction sites in Tanzania: Contractors’ practices and their perspectives”, Int. J. Constr. Eng. Manag, Vol.7, p.88096.
Bertagni, S., Boarin, P. and Zuppiroli, M. (2018), “The dialogue between structural interventions and sustainability criteria in rating systems for cultural heritage: The experience of gbc historic building”, International Journal of Architectural Heritage.
Osei-Tutu, S., Ayarkwa, J., Osei-Asibey, D., Nani, G. and Afful, A.E. (2022),” Barriers impeding circular economy (CE) uptake in the construction industry”, Smart and Sustainable Built Environment. 106
Najini, H., Nour, M., Al-Zuhair, S. and Ghaith, F. (2020),” Techno-Economic Analysis of Green Building Codes in United Arab Emirates Based on a Case Study Office Building”, Sustainability, Vol.12, No.21, p.8773.
Ahmed, A., Li, W., Varjani, S. and You, S. (2022), “Waste-to-energy technologies for sustainability: Life-cycle assessment and economic analysis”, Biomass, Biofuels, Biochemicals, pp.599-612.
Lai, S.L. and Chen, D.N. (2020),” A research on the relationship between environmental sustainability management and human development”, Sustainability, Vol.12, No.21, p.9001.
Biswas, T., Wang, T.H. and Krishnamurti, R. (2013), “From design to pre-certification using building information modeling”, Journal of Green Building, Vol.8, No.1, pp.151-176.
Ugwua, O.O. and Haupt, T.C. (2007),” Key performance indicators and assessment methods for infrastructure sustainability—a South African construction industry perspective”, Building and Environment, Vol.42No.2,
Erol, I., Cakar, N., Erel, D. and Sari, R. (2009),” Sustainability in the Turkish retailing industry”, Sustainable Development, Vol.17, No.1, pp.49-67.
Chen, Y., Okudan, G.E. and Riley, D.R. (2010), “Sustainable performance criteria for construction method selection in concrete buildings”, Automation in construction, Vol.19, No.2, pp.235-244.
Kridlova-Burdova, E. and Vilčeková, S. (2012),” Environmental assessment of building materials and constructions”, Applied Mechanics and Materials, Vol.174, pp.3161-3165, Trans-Tech Publications Ltd.
Padgett, J.E. and Tapia, C. (2013),” Sustainability of natural hazard risk mitigation: Life cycle analysis of environmental indicators for bridge infrastructure”, Journal of Infrastructure Systems, Vol.19, No.4, pp.395-408.
Collier, Z.A., Wang, D., Vogel, J.T., Tatham, E.K. and Linkov, I. (2013), “Sustainable roofing technology under multiple constraints: a decision-analytical approach”, Environment Systems and Decisions, Vol.33, pp.261-271.
Kucukvar, M., Noori, M., Egilmez, G. and Tatari, O. (2014),” Stochastic decision modeling for sustainable pavement designs”, The international journal of life cycle assessment, Vol.19, pp.1185-1199.
Chou, J.S. and Ongkowijoyo, C.S. (2014), “Risk-based group decision-making regarding renewable energy schemes using a stochastic graphical matrix model”, Automation in Construction, Vol.37, pp.98-109.
Wibowo, S. and Deng, H. (2015),” multi-criteria group decision-making for evaluating the performance of ewaste recycling programs under uncertainty”, Waste Management, Vol.40, pp.127-135.
Afful-Dadzie, A., Afful-Dadzie, E. and Turkson, C. (2016), “A TOPSIS extension framework for re-conceptualizing sustainability measurement”, Kybernetes.
Li, L., Fan, F., Ma, L. and Tang, Z. (2016),” Energy utilization evaluation of carbon performance in public projects by FAHP and cloud model”, Sustainability, Vol.8, No.7, p.630.
Ding, Y.Q., Zou, S.H. and Yu, C.W. (2016),” A new comprehensive evaluating method for assessing the sustainability credentials of the central air-conditioning system”, Indoor and Built Environment, Vol.25, No.6,
Govindan, K., Garg, K., Gupta, S. and Jha, P.C. (2016),” Effect of product recovery and sustainability enhancing indicators on the location selection of manufacturing facility”, Ecological indicators, Vol.67, pp.517-532.
Zhao, H., Guo, S. and Zhao, H. (2017),” Comprehensive benefit evaluation of eco-industrial parks by employing the best-worst method based on circular economy and sustainability”, Environment, development and sustainability, Vol.20, pp.1229-1253.
Hojjati, A., Jefferson, I., Metje, N. and Rogers, C.D. (2017), “Embedding sustainability criteria into pre-appraisal of underground utility for future cities”, Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Urban Design and Planning,
Jafari, A. and Valentin, V. (2018),” Proposing a conceptual decision support system for building energy retrofits considering sustainable triple bottom line criteria”, Construction Research Congress, pp.553-563.
Jovanović, M.P., Vučićević, B.S., Turanjanin, V.M., Lazović, I.M. and Živković, M.M. (2018), “Assessing the sustainability of Serbian school buildings by analyse and syntesis parameters under information deficiency method”, Thermal Science, Vol.22, No.4, pp.1271-1283.
Yang, W. and Jiang, X. (2018),” Evaluating sustainable urbanization of resource-based cities based on the McKinsey matrix: Case study in China”, Journal of Urban Planning and Development, Vol.144, No.1, p.05017020.
BuHamdan, S., Alwisy, A., Bouferguene, A. and Al-Hussein, M. (2019), “The application of multi-attribute utility theory for a market share-based design evaluation”, International Journal of Housing Markets and Analysis,
Su, X., Chiang, P., Pan, S., Chen, G., Tao, Y., Wu, G., Wang, F. and Cao, W. (2019),” Systematic approach to evaluating environmental and ecological technologies for wastewater treatment”, Chemosphere, Vol.218,
Cheng, R. and Li, W. (2019), “Evaluating environmental sustainability of an urban industrial plan under the threeline environmental governance policy in China”, Journal of environmental management, Vol.251, p.109545.
Reddy, A.S., Kumar, P.R. and Anand-Raj, P. (2021),” Assessing interdependency among sustainable criteria and indicators for developing a building assessment tool”, International Journal of Sustainable Engineering, Vol.14,
Artelt, C. and Lukas, P. (2020),” Sustainable product portfolio evaluation methodology for sustainability reporting in the cement and concrete industry”, European Journal of Sustainable Development, Vol.9, No.1, pp.66-66.
Kokkinos, K. and Karayannis, V. (2020),” Supportiveness of low-carbon energy technology policy using fuzzy multicriteria decision-making methodologies”, Mathematics, Vol.8, No.7, p.1178.
Wang, L., Zhang, P., Ma, L., Cong, X. and Skibniewski, M.J. (2020),” Developing a corporate social responsibility framework for sustainable construction using partial least squares structural equation modeling”, Technological and Economic Development of Economy, Vol.26, No.1, pp.186-212.
Artino, A., Caponetto, R., Evola, G., Margani, G., Marino, E.M. and Murgano, E. (2020), “Decision Support System for the Sustainable Seismic and Energy Renovation of Buildings: Methodological Layout”, Sustainability, Vol.12, No.24, p.10273.
Hendiani, S., Sharifi, E., Bagherpour, M. and Ghannadpour, S.F. (2020),” A multi-criteria sustainability assessment approach for energy systems using sustainability triple bottom line attributes and linguistic preferences”, Environment, Development and Sustainability, Vol.22, pp.7771-7805.
Chen, Y. and Zhang, D. (2020), “Evaluation of city sustainability using multi-criteria decision-making considering interaction among criteria in Liaoning province China”, Sustainable Cities and Society, Vol.59, p.102211.
Nara, E.O.B., da Costa, M.B., Baierle, I.C., Schaefer, J.L., Benitez, G.B., do Santos, L.M.A.L. and Benitez, L.B. (2021),” Expected impact of industry 4.0 technologies on sustainable development: A study in the context of Brazil's plastic industry”, Sustainable Production and Consumption, Vol.25, pp.102-122.
Khan, S.N., Mian, H.R., Hewage, K. and Sadiq, R. (2021),” Environmental and economic performance of a water distribution system through a lens of life cycle thinking: a case study of the City of Kelowna”, Sustainable and Resilient Infrastructure, pp.1-22.
Aktaş, N.A.D.İ.D.E. and Demirel, N.E.S.L.İ.H.A.N. (2021), “A hybrid framework for evaluating corporate sustainability using multi-criteria decision making”, Environment, Development and Sustainability, Vol.23, No.10,
Hong, Y., Ezeh, C.I., Deng, W., Hong, S.H., Ma, Y., Tang, Y. and Jin, Y. (2021),” Coordinated energy-environmentaleconomic optimisation of building retrofits for optimal energy performance on a macro-scale: A life-cycle costbased evaluation”, Energy Conversion and Management, Vol.243, p.114327.
Ghosh, S., Mandal, M.C. and Ray, A. (2021),” An exploratory assessment of the sustainability performance of the construction industry”, Int J Industrial Engineering: Theory Appl Pract, Vol.28, No.3, pp.329-353.
Erdogan, H. and Tosun, N. (2021), “Evaluation of sustainable supplier problem: A hybrid decision making model based on SWARA-WASPAS”, LogForum, Vol.17, No.4.
Andersen, S.C., Sohn, J., Oldfield, P. and Birkved, M. (2022), “Evaluating the environmental impacts of conventional and modular buildings in absolute measures: A case study across different geographical contexts”, Building and Environment, Vol.223, p.109509.
Sánchez-Garrido, A.J., Navarro, I.J. and Yepes, V. (2022),” Evaluating the sustainability of soil improvement techniques in foundation substructures”, Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol.351, p.131463.
Khokhar, M., Zia, S., Islam, T., Sharma, A., Iqbal, W. and Irshad, M. (2022), “Going green supply chain management during covid-19, assessing the best supplier selection criteria: a triple bottom line approach”, Problemy Ekorozwoju, Vol.17, No.1.
Zhang, R. and Xu, Y. (2022),” The Air Quality Impact Evaluation of Modular Construction Practices in Hong Kong and Singapore”, Sustainability, Vol.14, No.2, p.1016.
Di Maria, A., Merchán, M., Marchand, M., Eguizabal, D., De Cortázar, M.G. and Van Acker, K. (2022), “Evaluating energy and resource efficiency for recovery of metallurgical residues using environmental and economic analysis”, Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol.356, p.131790.
Ramakrishnan, J., Liu, T., Zhang, F., Seshadri, K., Yu, R. and Gou, Z. (2023),” A decision tree-based modeling approach for evaluating the green performance of airport buildings”, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, Vol,100, p.107070.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Sidik, M. A., El Fathali H. I., Ayarkwa, J., Acheampong, A., Osei-Tutu, S., Afful, A. E.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.