An Assessment of the Existence, Nature and Role of Current Internal Controls Being Applied at Lobels Bread, a Bread and Confectionary Manufacturer, Based in the Bulawayo Metropolitan Province in Zimbabwe

Authors

  • Kenneth Tavarwisa Business Administration and Accounting Department, Atlantic International University (AIU), 900 Fort Street Mall, #905, Honolulu, HI 96813, USA

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.14738/aivp.1401.19895

Keywords:

Internal Controls, Efficiency, Effectiveness, Competitive Position, Financial distress

Abstract

 The research investigates and evaluates the existence, nature and role of internal controls at Lobels Bread Private Limited, a company facing financial distress, with the aim of identifying areas of weakness and providing recommendations to avoid and prevent collapse using a descriptive survey research design.  The study employed questionnaires and interviews as tools for data collection, targeting 40 employees selected using stratified random sampling technique. The questionnaire consisted of both open- ended and closed- ended questions, while in-depth interviews were conducted with key personnel including the Finance Manager and Internal Auditor. The study reveals that Lobels Bread has a partially implemented internal control system with some controls in place but lacking comprehensiveness and effectiveness. The company’s control environment is characterized by inadequate segregation of duties, lack of clear policies and procedures, and insufficient monitoring and review processes. The study also identifies significant weaknesses in the company’s internal controls, including inadequate accounting and financial reporting systems, poor inventory management and lack of effective risk management policies. The findings of the study indicate that the internal controls at Lobels bread are not effective in preventing financial distress, and that the company is at risk of collapse if the weaknesses are not addressed. The study provide practical recommendations for Lobels bread to improve its internal controls , including strengthening the control environment , improving accounting and financial reporting systems, enhancing inventory management and establishing effective risk management processes. The study contributes to the existing literature on controls and financial distress, and provides insights into the importance of effective internal controls in preventing financial distress. The findings of this study are relevant to companies facing financial distress and can be used to inform strategies for improving internal controls and preventing collapse.

References

Julie (2003), “ Internal control measures in corporations,” 10/07

“The effect of Internal control deficiencies on firm risk and cost of equity,” Journal of accounting Research 47 (2009) 1-43

Bedard J and L Graham : Factors affecting the internal control deficiencies : Archival evidence working paper, Bentley college 2008

Bronson, sj Carcello and K Raghinandan “ Firm Characteristics and voluntary management reports on internal control,” Auditing: A Journal of practice and theory 25 (2006) 25-39 Scholar Publishing

Feng M , CU and S Mcvary “ Internal control and management guidance,” Journal of accounting and economics (2009)

Hoitash, RU Hoitash and J Berdad : Internal control quality : Audit , A Journal of practice and theory 27 (2008) 105 – 126

Mcmullen, D A Raghunandan A and K Rama : Internal control reports and Financial reporting problems : Accounting horizons 10 (1996) 67-75

PCAOB : Auditing Standards No 2 , An Audit of internal control over financial reporting performed in conjunction with an audit of financial statements PCAOB; (2004)

Salterio S and R Schmidt : Management’s evaluation of design effectiveness of internal controls over financial reporting : Weak regulation and inconsistent compliance. Draft October 14 2007

M C Jensen : Theory of the firm : the journal of finance . Harvard University Press (2000) 31-70

Cox, George, Grace, Stephen and John Hauport: A prescription of company health . The CPA Journal V 72 (July 2002) 1-3

Institute of Internal Auditors “ Internal Auditors : Integral to good Corporate governance. (August 2002) 1-6

Well Joseph T : Occupational Fraud . The Audit as deterrent . Journal of Accountancy 193 ( April 2002) 1-8

A H Millichamp , 1996, “Auditing Manual pages 79-92.

Tom Lee 1998, “Corporate Audit

George Puttick . Instructional Manual for Accounting students. 2004 page 114 -213.

J.K Loebbecke 1996. “An Intergrated Audit Approach”, page 238-247.

Ray Whittington , Kurt Pany , Walter B Meigs and Robert E Meigs. 2006. Principles of Auditing ”, page 226 - 310.

Vivian R V Cooper ( 1967 ) Manual of Auditing page 11-45

Lawrence L Vance “ Principles of Auditing” 1975 page 12-80

Drucker and Peter F (2006), The effective executive

Wickipadea. Internet www. business directory .com 26/06.2010

Smit,P.J.and Cronje, G.J 2003 . Management Principles- a contemporary edition for Africa 3RD EDITION . Juta & Co.

B H Walley (1974),Efficiency Auditing, Macmillan Press

Daniel G Brathwaite (1988), New Approach for Internal Auditors, D & J Publishing

R Howard 9th Edition (1992), Auditing , Longman Group

T A Lee(1988), Foundation of Accounting, Garland Publishing

Andrew Chambers and Graham Rand (1994), Auditing the IT environment, Pitman

ACCA Professional Paper 10 (2000), Accounting and Audit Practice, BPP Publishing

B Geist (1981), Developments in Public Accountability, The Macmillan Press

David Hoyle (1997), ISO9000 Quality system assessment , Butterworth Heinemann

ACCA (2000), Auditing ACCA Lectures Manual , 2nd Edition- Longman

Brian Dawes (1995), International Business, Stanely Thomas Publisher Scholar Publishing

Malcom Smith (1995), New Tools for Management, Pitman

Taylor Krintzinger Puttick (1987), The Principles and Practice of Auditing- Juta

Kurt Payne and O Ray Whittington , 2nd Edition (1997), Auditing , Irwin

Bernard C Williams and Barry J Spaul (1991), The impact of Information Technology- Chapman and Hall

John Page and Paul Hooper , 4th Edition , (1992), Accounting and Information Systems- Prentice Hall

ACCA Paper 6 (1994), Audit Framework – Foulks and Lynch

Michael Sherer and Stuart Turley (1991) Current Issues in Auditing , 2nd Edition – Paul Chapman Publishing

Coopers and Lybrand (1993), Student’s Manual of Auditing, 3rd Edition – TJ Press

Leed, P D 1980. Practiceal Research & Design . New York Macmillan

Moore, P G 1986, Basic Operations Research 3rd Edition Pitman

Muchengetwa, S2005 Statistics Study Pack Institute of Administration and Commerce

Saunders, M,. Lewis , P., Thornhill A 2007 Research Methods for Business Students. 4th Edition . England : Prentice Hall.

Smit , P.J and Cronje GJ 2003 . Management Principles – a contemporary Edition for Africa, 3rd Edition . Juta & Co.

Wyatt, R 1999. Computer – Aided Policymaking. E & FN Spon

Was, VJ and Wells PE 1994 Principles and Practice in Business and Management Research . 1st Edition Dartmouth

Walonick DS 2004 Survival Statistics. Stapac Inc.

Downloads

Published

2026-01-27

How to Cite

Tavarwisa, K. (2026). An Assessment of the Existence, Nature and Role of Current Internal Controls Being Applied at Lobels Bread, a Bread and Confectionary Manufacturer, Based in the Bulawayo Metropolitan Province in Zimbabwe. European Journal of Applied Sciences, 14(01), 323–361. https://doi.org/10.14738/aivp.1401.19895